Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
History of Feminism
In reply to the discussion: Shout out to my friends in the History of Feminism group [View all]seabeyond
(110,159 posts)41. review of full frontal feminism
Full Frontal Feminism is damn good. It is, very much, a love letter to feminism and a feminist primer. It is not a book that is meant to appeal to career feminists, or to women who have made feminism their lives however, I am a woman who has pretty much made feminism her life, and I really enjoyed it and I learned from it. The point of Jessicas book, though, is to explain to younger women why feminism is appealing, and why its valid in their lives. It explains why feminism has been important in Jessicas life. FFF is appealing precisely because its conversational. Jessicas writing is so incredibly tight that she can take complicated topics and distill them down to compelling one-sentence summaries followed by fuck that, or some otherwise perfect, funny and to-the-point dismissal. She takes issues that would take me pages to explain and pares them down to a paragraph. And youre laughing by the end of it. FFF is not an academic work, and was never intended to be. Its informative without being intimidating; its intelligent and still accessible. Reading it is a lot like talking to Jessica in person charming, funny, cutting, sometimes foul-mouthed, intelligent, and always fascinating.
Jessica and I differ on several issues, porn and statutory rape being the two that come most immediately to mind. But damn if she doesnt present solid, grounded arguments for her points of view. And while we may not agree on everything, the fact is that Jessica gets it. She is well-schooled in both academic feminism as well as day-to-day, life-lesson feminism and as a general rule she errs on the side of lived feminism, which is incredibly refreshing. Ive done the academic feminism thing hell, Im still doing it and while I love me some theory, at the end of the day, the way women live their lives and negotiate feminism with their lived realities matters a whole lot more than theory ever will. So her book isnt laden with academic terms. Jessica isnt trying to remind you that shes smarter and more feminist than you are. And after spending a semester reading Butler and Foucault, sitting down with Full Frontal Feminism was a nice change. I could read it, be entertained, learn something, and not feel like I was having to work at it.
Full Frontal Feminism is intended to target younger women high school and early college-aged would be my guess. I didnt identify as a feminist until college, not because I didnt have feminist beliefs, but because I hadnt met anyone my own age who identified as feminist, and because I bought into a lot of the negative stereotypes about feminism. If you had thrown Andrea Dworkin or Judith Butler at 16-year-old Jill, she would have told you it was the most ridiculous thing she had ever read and thrown it back at you. But if you had given me Full Frontal Feminism, I would have thought twice about the feminist label. That was Jessicas point not to impress the theory-whores out there. Not to convert the 25-year-old grad student. Not to open the eyes of the 60-year-old veteran feminist who spent her whole life on the front lines. But to reach out to the younger women who have been scared away from feminism by the conservative backlash and an unsympathetic media.
Thats incredibly important. And thats why so many of the criticisms of Full Frontal Feminism have pissed me off so much.
*
You dont have to agree with everything Jessica writes, or how she writes it, or how she packages it. Criticism is crucial to building a more effective movement, and to making us all better people. But the snipes and the little cruelties leveled at Jessica are making my skin crawl. I want to believe that we can be constructive in our criticisms, that we can realize that were all trying to make progress toward gender equality and/or womens liberation, and that even if we go about it in different ways, our hearts are in the right place. I want to believe that, while feminism may not unite us, it will at least offer some common ground. I want to believe that even if we quibble on the details, we will nonetheless support each other and have each others backs. I want to believe that we wont cut each other down in the way that the rest of the whole fucking world cuts us down. It makes me incredibly sad to know that that isnt the case.
Jessica is doing the hard work of making feminism accessible to a wide range of younger women. She is at the forefront of online feminist activism. She is well-versed in feminist theory. She is someone who Im happy to see taking the lead in my generation of feminists. She is one of the kindest, smartest, most generous people I have ever met. She should be incredibly proud of what shes accomplished. Im incredibly proud of her. And I offer her my sincerest congratulations on a job well done.
http://www.feministe.us/blog/archives/2007/05/16/full-frontal-feminism/
Jessica and I differ on several issues, porn and statutory rape being the two that come most immediately to mind. But damn if she doesnt present solid, grounded arguments for her points of view. And while we may not agree on everything, the fact is that Jessica gets it. She is well-schooled in both academic feminism as well as day-to-day, life-lesson feminism and as a general rule she errs on the side of lived feminism, which is incredibly refreshing. Ive done the academic feminism thing hell, Im still doing it and while I love me some theory, at the end of the day, the way women live their lives and negotiate feminism with their lived realities matters a whole lot more than theory ever will. So her book isnt laden with academic terms. Jessica isnt trying to remind you that shes smarter and more feminist than you are. And after spending a semester reading Butler and Foucault, sitting down with Full Frontal Feminism was a nice change. I could read it, be entertained, learn something, and not feel like I was having to work at it.
Full Frontal Feminism is intended to target younger women high school and early college-aged would be my guess. I didnt identify as a feminist until college, not because I didnt have feminist beliefs, but because I hadnt met anyone my own age who identified as feminist, and because I bought into a lot of the negative stereotypes about feminism. If you had thrown Andrea Dworkin or Judith Butler at 16-year-old Jill, she would have told you it was the most ridiculous thing she had ever read and thrown it back at you. But if you had given me Full Frontal Feminism, I would have thought twice about the feminist label. That was Jessicas point not to impress the theory-whores out there. Not to convert the 25-year-old grad student. Not to open the eyes of the 60-year-old veteran feminist who spent her whole life on the front lines. But to reach out to the younger women who have been scared away from feminism by the conservative backlash and an unsympathetic media.
Thats incredibly important. And thats why so many of the criticisms of Full Frontal Feminism have pissed me off so much.
*
You dont have to agree with everything Jessica writes, or how she writes it, or how she packages it. Criticism is crucial to building a more effective movement, and to making us all better people. But the snipes and the little cruelties leveled at Jessica are making my skin crawl. I want to believe that we can be constructive in our criticisms, that we can realize that were all trying to make progress toward gender equality and/or womens liberation, and that even if we go about it in different ways, our hearts are in the right place. I want to believe that, while feminism may not unite us, it will at least offer some common ground. I want to believe that even if we quibble on the details, we will nonetheless support each other and have each others backs. I want to believe that we wont cut each other down in the way that the rest of the whole fucking world cuts us down. It makes me incredibly sad to know that that isnt the case.
Jessica is doing the hard work of making feminism accessible to a wide range of younger women. She is at the forefront of online feminist activism. She is well-versed in feminist theory. She is someone who Im happy to see taking the lead in my generation of feminists. She is one of the kindest, smartest, most generous people I have ever met. She should be incredibly proud of what shes accomplished. Im incredibly proud of her. And I offer her my sincerest congratulations on a job well done.
http://www.feministe.us/blog/archives/2007/05/16/full-frontal-feminism/
a lot more in the article. it was interesting. thank you for mentioning. this seems one of the more fair and balanced critiques
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
41 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
generously, they quickly got me off the double secret probation and now just waiting final day, ...
seabeyond
Dec 2013
#3
Don't look now, but several of your old compatriots are trying to whip shit up again.
PassingFair
Dec 2013
#11
honestly, the people that stood with yardwork seem to feel about the same. those whipping up the
seabeyond
Dec 2013
#14
And a Happy New Year shout out to you, Durham D. You were the one who asked me to take another look.
yardwork
Dec 2013
#21
When I stopped viewing you as an opponent, we started having productive conversations that I have en
AtheistCrusader
Dec 2013
#32