Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

ChicagoTeamster

(1,157 posts)
25. There are no military options that won't be ungodly costly for both sides. Terrain around the Gulf favors the defender
Thu Apr 30, 2026, 02:42 PM
Thursday

If they bomb infrastructure they not only commit war crimes but Iran and their proxies will do the same to all of the neighboring Gulf countries and eventually successfully get a coordinated terror and missile attack on an Israeli city or maybe multiple to enhance the damage and destruction. Israeli citizens are already leaving. Israel also has ports that may become targets for Iranian sea drones that can be deployed by their proxies in the region.

Iran has already neutralized our support systems in the region hence the bad food situation on ships. What is the medical resupply situation should the US commit to more direct action? Can our ships and personnel be resupplied with munitions, spare and repair parts, and fuel in a reasonable amount of time and without risking loss of the resupply ships or aircraft?

If Gulf allies see that we can't maintain and protect our own forces, what will they think of our ability to defend them? How will that assessment affect their future cooperation with the US?

There is more to consider than just offensive options.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

I hope they have big pictures to keep him awake. He's likely to sleep through the meeting. Lonestarblue Thursday #1
Rule #1 Botany Thursday #2
You are so right. I wonder if the commanders have an unfuck plan? liberalla Thursday #13
Hope they're prepared to stand up to him when he starts screaming about dropping nukes. tanyev Thursday #3
If he can stay awake long enough. nt BWdem4life Thursday #4
Trumps approach is nothing its will all pass just like covid the shiney new toy isn't so new. Historic NY Thursday #5
With Trump being not-so-much-to-pay-attention-what's-going-on... chouchou Thursday #6
Gas prices are continuing to rapidly rise Renew Deal Thursday #7
RAPIDLY!!! Up 60 cents at one station between yesterday at 4pm and this morning at 7!!! Prairie Gates Thursday #10
Wow! Renew Deal Thursday #11
Few hours later today and it's around 4.28 Renew Deal Thursday #35
Unless they are profiting from it somehow IronLionZion Thursday #33
Hope they like talking to a wall.....the psychopath doesn't have clue unless he can put his name on it........ turbinetree Thursday #8
Yeesh Prairie Gates Thursday #9
The genius part was landing them Miguelito Loveless Thursday #18
So... 2naSalit Thursday #12
What Commanders ???? dave99 Thursday #14
From the end of Seymour Hersh's latest piece... Pluvious Thursday #15
Watch him blab everything to Putin Yo_Mama_Been_Loggin Thursday #16
Those options are: Miguelito Loveless Thursday #17
There are only two long term options: 1: Accept Iran's demands, declare victory and leave. This is by far the best Fil1957 Thursday #19
It's hard to really get that Trump really loves war and killing. ananda Thursday #20
How about this - get out of the fucking straight and Trump and Hegseth should go to prison! Initech Thursday #21
All I really want to know: barbtries Thursday #22
Nuke. LudwigPastorius Thursday #23
Why is Washington's professional football team generalbetrayus Thursday #24
There are no military options that won't be ungodly costly for both sides. Terrain around the Gulf favors the defender ChicagoTeamster Thursday #25
kick Dawson Leery Thursday #26
;-{) PLANS Goonch Thursday #27
JFC Skittles Thursday #28
tRump had an hour and a half call with his boss, putin, so I'm sure he already knows what must be done. nt yaesu Thursday #29
None of the three options in the article have a snowball's chance in hell of succeeding. flashman13 Thursday #30
I think Donald, as Major Kong, riding the bomb down, should be an option struggle4progress Thursday #31
Is declare victory and leave an option? IronLionZion Thursday #32
What was he briefed? Anyone know? ChicagoTeamster Thursday #34
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Scoop: Commanders to brie...»Reply #25