MaddowBlog-In first big test of Trump's second term, voters tell GOP what it didn't want to hear [View all]
After November, many suggested Republicans had entered an era of electoral dominance. Now, its Democrats who are celebrating.
After the 2024 elections, the conventional wisdom suggested that Republicans had entered an era of electoral dominance.
A lot can change in six months. www.msnbc.com/rachel-maddo...
— Steve Benen (@stevebenen.com) 2025-04-02T13:04:09.853Z
After the 2024 elections, the conventional wisdom suggested that Republicans had entered an era of electoral dominance.
A lot can change in six months
https://www.msnbc.com/rachel-maddow-show/maddowblog/first-big-test-trumps-second-term-voters-tell-gop-didnt-want-hear-rcna199243
A few days later, voters in the Badger State rendered their verdict and it wasnt the one Musk and other Republicans wanted to hear. As my MSNBC colleague Clarissa-Jan Lim summarized overnight:
Liberal candidate Susan Crawford has won the Wisconsin Supreme Court election, NBC News projected Tuesday, preserving a liberal majority on the swing states highest court. Crawford, a circuit court judge in Dane County, defeated Brad Schimel, a Waukesha County circuit court judge and former Republican state attorney general.
.....As the dust settles on the most important electoral tests of Trumps second term, weve learned a few things about the electoral landscape.
Musk wont save Republican candidates: The presidents top campaign donor spent millions in the hopes of pushing Schimel to victory in Wisconsin, and it backfired, with Democrats ultimately running against Musk, whom they accused of trying to buy the election. Theres a lesson here for GOP officials whove falsely assumed that Musk is popular with the American mainstream and whove operated from the assumption that the billionaire can help carry them across the finish line in 2026.
Democrats will be running against Musk a lot in the coming months: Trumps unpopularity matters, but Musks unpopularity runs deeper. If youre thinking the billionaire will be a centerpiece of Democratic messaging going forward, youre right.
Republicans in competitive districts have reason to worry: The GOP thought it could run the 2024 playbook in a battleground state that Trump narrowly won, counting on that recipe to keep working. It failed badly. Republicans representing districts that were highly competitive last year are now confronted with a choice: Ignore the prevailing winds, stick with their party and hope for the best, or start putting some distance between themselves and the GOP.
Trumps endorsements are of limited value: Once again, Trump told voters to turn out for an ally. Once again, it didnt matter. Theres no denying that the president has a loyal base, but to assume that base will necessarily rally behind his preferred candidates is a mistake.
Reassessing the Democratic brand: Democratic Sen. Michael Bennet of Colorado told NBC News over the weekend that his partys brand is problematic. Around the same time, Californias Democratic governor, Gavin Newsom, said the Democratic brand is toxic. Days earlier, Democratic Sen. John Fetterman of Pennsylvania told Politico, If we dont get our s--- together, then we are going to be in a permanent minority.
......In the aftermath of Election Day 2024, the conventional wisdom suggested not only that Republicans had entered an era of electoral dominance, but also that Democratic voters were demoralized, disheartened and prepared to withdraw from civic life for a long while.
A lot has changed in six months.