Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

morillon

(1,248 posts)
15. AI and ML are a whole spectrum of things
Sun Dec 1, 2024, 07:55 PM
Dec 1

And it's easy to get terms mixed up or conflate one with another. I say that as someone who works in the biz, mostly with NLUs and some privately trained LLMs, and who still has to constantly educate myself to keep things straight. The field is changing a lot, and fast.

Software development is my day job, but I'm also a professional writer, fiction and non-fiction. I share fellow creatives' concerns about the way the big LLMs were trained and how they're being used to spew out a constant stream of drek. I'm happy there's a backlash against newsrooms who've tried to replace actual writers with GenAI.

I actually wouldn't lump Hemingway in with GenAI. It's not like ChatGPT or Sudowrite or other generative tools. It's a rules-based natural language processor, and as a writer, I don't have any ethical concerns about it at all.

I don't use generative-capable AIs to produce text. Ethical considerations aside, the text that comes out feels to me like the literary equivalent of the Uncanny Valley. Its writerly voice is just...echhhh.

But I've used ChatGPT to argue with. I try to explain my plot, it second-guesses the shit out of me, and by the time I'm done justifying my choices, I feel a helluva lot more confident about my story. It can be really useful for that.

I'm glad to hear you're finding joy in writing, FirstLight, and if Hemingway is making you feel more confident about your story, I think that's awesome and a great use of the technology.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Interesting. I've self published six books. Working on book 7. I'll check it out. Best of luck with the book! Joinfortmill Dec 1 #1
I'd be interested in how/where you do it... FirstLight Dec 1 #2
I publish 'wide', which means I'm not exclusive to Amazon, but... Joinfortmill Dec 1 #4
Yeah, im only using it for general detection ... FirstLight Dec 1 #9
All those generative AI tools are trained on stolen intellectual property. Most real writers absolutely hate highplainsdem Dec 1 #3
And btw, I think it's a very safe bet that Hemingway would absolutely despise AI tools for highplainsdem Dec 1 #5
Im not using it for generating my stuff, but I see FirstLight Dec 1 #10
AI is used for the wrong reasons. keithbvadu2 Dec 1 #6
Well said... Think. Again. Dec 1 #14
Here's a Bluesky thread about the Hemingway App that you should see. Their AI doesn't like Hemingway's writing. highplainsdem Dec 1 #7
Why don't you just.... Think. Again. Dec 1 #8
Okay I am not using it to write for me! FirstLight Dec 1 #11
I apologize. Think. Again. Dec 1 #13
AI is scary. It threatens people's concept of superiority... mikelewis Dec 1 #12
AI and ML are a whole spectrum of things morillon Dec 1 #15
I force GPT to Argue with itself when I can't keep up...LOL mikelewis Dec 1 #17
Yeah, I don't find it intimidating, either morillon Dec 1 #18
There's just 2d math driving current AI... mikelewis Dec 2 #19
Post removed Post removed Dec 1 #16
Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Writing»OK, I am a huge AI hater....»Reply #15