Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

jimmy the one

(2,720 posts)
29. weasel words
Mon Mar 14, 2022, 12:18 PM
Mar 2022

guru: It is ridiculous to argue the "right" to keep and bear arms is possessed only by those citizens enrolled in the militia

So ridiculous it's been argued for 230 years as either full or militia centric to original intent in 1791, and until scalia via heller subverted 2ndA the militia rkba was largely accepted as the proper interpretation of original intent.
You are a pro gun sophist.
Weasel is kinda synonymous with sophistry.

Below, read what guru quoted from presser in his preceding post, and note the ellipses, the 3 dots after 'arms,', indicating a partial quote with more to come. Guru clipped the sentence by inserting 3 dot ellipses for the sentence remainder:

guru above: ... the states cannot, even laying the constitutional provision in question out of view, prohibit the people from keeping and bearing arms, . . . "

Leads readers to believe states could not prohibit the people from gun rights, eh?
Guru clipped off the remaining part of the sentence, quelle surprise, for it debunked his own argument.
Here is the fuller sentence in context:

scotus 1886 presser quote: ... the states cannot, even laying the constitutional provision in question out of view, prohibit the people from keeping and bearing arms, so as to deprive the United States of their rightful resource for maintaining the public security, and disable the people from performing their duty to the general government. But, as already stated, we think it clear that the sections under consideration do not have this effect. https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/116/252

Guru evidently does not understand the diff between 'public security' and a 'collective duty to the general govt', from individual gun ownership. Or was guru citing a far right wing gun source? he was disinclined from posting links.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

NEVER Going To Stop Guns In America SoCalDavidS Jan 2022 #1
Strange..............43 posts and I can see only 15 of them. oneshooter Mar 2022 #43
Huh? SoCalDavidS Mar 2022 #44
17 posts have been dropped. oneshooter Oct 2022 #45
Have added some folks to ignore? n/t discntnt_irny_srcsm Oct 2022 #46
I do not put people on ignore. oneshooter Oct 2022 #47
If you have an add blocker... discntnt_irny_srcsm Oct 2022 #48
Had Democrats not pushed for gun control so strongly over the last few decades, Dial H For Hero Jan 2022 #2
Am I the only one melm00se Jan 2022 #3
I see them all. discntnt_irny_srcsm Jan 2022 #4
Are they too small, or are you getting broken links? n/t krispos42 Jan 2022 #5
It might be because the picture links.. krispos42 Jan 2022 #6
broken links melm00se Jan 2022 #7
Deafening silence. krispos42 Jan 2022 #8
The antigun activists on this site haven't the faintest interest in debating facts. Dial H For Hero Jan 2022 #9
Yeah, well. I had a beaut of a response for you, and I chickened out. Paladin Jan 2022 #10
Intriguing reply indeed krispos42 Jan 2022 #11
shall issue ccw was not wanted in the first place jimmy the one Feb 2022 #12
Some of this is specious melm00se Mar 2022 #13
re: "Can something be made more illegal?" discntnt_irny_srcsm Mar 2022 #14
Like the log I heard some businesses make you do to log your work time? yagotme Mar 2022 #15
my unanimous decision trumps yours jimmy the one Mar 2022 #16
re: Miller... looking to move in standup comedy? n/t discntnt_irny_srcsm Mar 2022 #18
re: juvenile ad hominem jimmy the one Mar 2022 #19
Okay discntnt_irny_srcsm Mar 2022 #20
No one objected, because Miller was deceased, yagotme Mar 2022 #21
Re: "my unanimous decision trumps yours" Surf Fishing Guru Mar 2022 #22
1939 Miller decision, cont'd #1 jimmy the one Mar 2022 #23
RE: 1939 Miller decision, cont'd #1 Surf Fishing Guru Mar 2022 #28
weasel words jimmy the one Mar 2022 #29
That sounds like confession by projection from you. Surf Fishing Guru Mar 2022 #32
prior state's right to bear arms decrees circa 1776 jimmy the one Mar 2022 #24
RE: State RKBA provisions Surf Fishing Guru Mar 2022 #30
bluntly speaking jimmy the one Mar 2022 #25
Bluntly true . . . Surf Fishing Guru Mar 2022 #31
provide links or excerpts for 'dissents' jimmy the one Mar 2022 #33
You couldn't have read the dissents . . . Surf Fishing Guru Mar 2022 #34
You can read but you cannot comprehend much jimmy the one Mar 2022 #35
That's some inventive reading . . . Surf Fishing Guru Mar 2022 #36
SUDDENLY, an excoriation jimmy the one Mar 2022 #37
Take a breath, calm down . . . Surf Fishing Guru Mar 2022 #38
Post removed Post removed Mar 2022 #40
Post removed Post removed Mar 2022 #41
Post removed Post removed Mar 2022 #42
Sorry, not sorry, sanctimonious is what I do . . . Surf Fishing Guru Mar 2022 #39
a blast from the past jimmy the one Mar 2022 #26
scalia erred in heller -1 jimmy the one Mar 2022 #27
mel's smoke and mirrors jimmy the one Mar 2022 #17
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Gun Control & RKBA»35 years of gun sales, sh...»Reply #29