Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

LGBT Civil Rights and Activism

BrienDoesIt

(93 posts) Wed Nov 16, 2022, 05:14 PM Nov 2022

Does this new law allow states to discriminate against gay people? [View all]

I'd like to hear others' opinions. I very much consider this a half step back. Right now, the state is forced to recognize and provide SSM licenses.

If obergefell falls, does this or does this not allow states to discriminate by allowing them to ban SSM in their states even if they're forced to recognize a SSM license from out of state?

I don't understand why people think this is a step forward. It removes some rights from us that we currently have.

17 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Does this new law allow states to discriminate against gay people? [View all] BrienDoesIt Nov 2022 OP

Looking forward to this discussion. ShazzieB Nov 2022 #1

Here's a decent article on how things could play out. Solly Mack Nov 2022 #2

So it's exactly as I thought - it still allows states to discriminate. BrienDoesIt Nov 2022 #5

It offers federal protections but if Obergefell falls, states that want to discriminate can, yes Solly Mack Nov 2022 #6

I think the fed protections are a good thing. Very much so. BrienDoesIt Nov 2022 #7

That is one of the many questions - how it plays out on the state level Solly Mack Nov 2022 #8

No one I'm discussing this with gets that. BrienDoesIt Nov 2022 #9

You need to look at two cases: 1) as it is now and 2) if the SC over turns same sex marriage rights karynnj Nov 2022 #3

I'm not asking for this law to not go through.... BrienDoesIt Nov 2022 #4

It isn't a step backwards. Just a tiny step forward as laws go. ColinC Nov 2022 #10

But isn't it giving states the right to deny you a marriage license? BrienDoesIt Nov 2022 #11

It is. Which is how it is already as far as the laws on the books. ColinC Nov 2022 #12

What good is the progress if, in order to be protected by it, I have to take a vacation to get it? BrienDoesIt Nov 2022 #14

That's kinda how progress works unfortunately ColinC Nov 2022 #15

You're not wrong. At all. BrienDoesIt Nov 2022 #17

It is not a step backwards because it ONLY has consequence if the SC acts karynnj Nov 2022 #13

I guess I don't see it this way. BrienDoesIt Nov 2022 #16