Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

WePurrsevere

(24,259 posts)
5. 1) Admixture/Ethnicity is not an exact science 2) Database (as mentioned) and...
Tue Aug 28, 2018, 04:03 AM
Aug 2018

3) Interpretation: Different DNA companies interpret the data differently and some are better at picking up smaller ethnic groups than others.

For instance as an adoptee searching for more info and bio-family I've tested at both Ancestry and 23andMe. (I've also uploaded my raw data to other testing companies). IME the ethnicity results I have on 23andMe match my (now) known ancestors (my tree on Ancestry) more closely than Ancestry does even after they've recently updated the data and they seem to go back further in time (hence 23andMe offers Neanderthal results and AncestryDNA does not). My experience with how far back they dig (aside from Neanderthal) is that my 23andMe results show that I have .5% Sub-Saharan African that doesn't show anywhere else. I thought it was cool but had read in a 23and Me forum that it was possibly 'noise' so pushed it out of my mind until my half-sister tested on 23andMe (to prove that we're sisters) and she has it as well. Anyeay, if you and your husband tested on 23andMe one of both of you might have Ashkenazi Jewish show up too or...

If you want to dig a bit deeper, you all could download your raw data and then upload it for free to GEDmatch's Genesis (I'm assuming your son tested recently on 23and Me and has the v5 chip if it's v4 reg GEDmatch works well): genesis.gedmatch.com Using the Admixture feature and, from this site's suggestions try Eurogenes and Jtest. If just you and your husband want to dig and tested at AncestryDNA I suggest regular GEDmatch.com since it has more tools available ATM.

When I first got my results back from various companies I was confused by the differences in ethnic percentages so did some hunting, found this article to be very helpful and highly recommend people read it if they've tested or are thinking about testing.
https://www.legalgenealogist.com/2014/05/18/admixture-not-soup-yet/free


I hope I'm clear enough. I woke up, couldn't go back to sleep so popped in DU for a bit sans coffee. Lol

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

They go by what they 2naSalit Aug 2018 #1
Another possibility, not all genetic make-up shows up in the tests. 3Hotdogs Aug 2018 #2
yup shanti Nov 2018 #22
It might be a recessive trait. procon Aug 2018 #3
DNA analysis has no "recessive traits" LakeSuperiorView Sep 2018 #14
If it,is under a few percent CanonRay Aug 2018 #4
1) Admixture/Ethnicity is not an exact science 2) Database (as mentioned) and... WePurrsevere Aug 2018 #5
I think I'm going to do 23 and Me. Didn't realize 23 and Ancestry don't test for all the Cousin Dupree Aug 2018 #7
23andMe certainly seems to dig just a bit farther back... WePurrsevere Aug 2018 #10
Your answer is fascinating. MontanaMama Aug 2018 #9
Privacy should always be considered and I always suggest... WePurrsevere Aug 2018 #11
Thank you! MontanaMama Aug 2018 #12
You seem quite knowledgeable about this subject so I'd like to ask you a question. argyl Sep 2018 #17
I'm far from an expert but will gladly try to help. WePurrsevere Sep 2018 #18
Thanks for the input. argyl Sep 2018 #19
NPR had a story about this. EVERY egg is a crap chute. my uncle had all his & wives done. pansypoo53219 Aug 2018 #6
Skipping a generation is not a possibility. LakeSuperiorView Sep 2018 #13
Thanks for your help, everyone Cousin Dupree Aug 2018 #8
FYI - TuxedoKat Sep 2018 #15
I got a 23 and Me update about a week ago. argyl Sep 2018 #16
Very small traces of DNA are to be expected LeftInTX Oct 2018 #20
I uploaded my DNA to DNALand it says 5.4% Ashkenazi, but I'm not LeftInTX Oct 2018 #21
Did you bring home the right baby? NurseJackie Sep 2019 #23
Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Ancestry/Genealogy»Our son had his DNA teste...»Reply #5