Israel/Palestine

yardwork

(69,643 posts)

11. Do you know any Jewish people?

Sun May 17, 2026, 10:02 AM

Sunday

The statement that "for so many years they have only heard Netanyahu and nobody else" is breathtakingly false.

I am not Jewish but I have known Jewish people all my life, and almost without exception those American Jews I know have been protesting Israel's actions, beginning long before Netanyahu took office.

I know a handful of scientists in Israel and they don't agree with Netanyahu and didn't vote for him.

How would you like it if somebody in another country, who never visited the U.S. and knew very little of our history, said:

Not all Americans and not all Christians are hateful of course, but for so many years they have only heard Trump and nobody else. It worked for Hitler....

My reaction to hearing that would be the following: This is a very uninformed comment. I don't like Trump or agree with anything he's doing, and neither do most of the people I know. I'm not going to listen to this person because they're woefully uninformed.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

6 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

mopinko RockCreek mtairyguy IbogaProject Mz Pip jfz9580m

68 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

I don't understand why people are just blind to Israeli terrorism and instead focus on just Muslim terrorism. [View all] Eko Sunday OP

Lucky enough to meet a couple of multigraincracker Sunday #1

Ditto malaise Sunday #2

The propaganda portrays Israel is "the good guys" and Muslims as "the bad guys" Orrex Sunday #3

Yes Israel has controlled the narrative here and elsewhere for a long time FakeNoose Sunday #8

Do you know any Jewish people? yardwork Sunday #11

Yes we have many Jewish groups in Pittsburgh and I have several friends and neighbors of the Jewish faith FakeNoose Sunday #36

So you are accusing your Jewish friends and neighbors of the following? yardwork Sunday #44

This message was self-deleted by its author Biophilic Sunday #47

Where are you seeing that? yardwork Sunday #9

Just out of curiosity... Orrex Sunday #21

Good question. I rarely use the AI results, but here goes... yardwork Sunday #23

We need to be careful not to conflate Jews as a people with the state of Israel Orrex Sunday #29

I was responding to your post above. yardwork Sunday #31

Ah yes--you did respond. My bad. Orrex Sunday #35

You have not. yardwork Sunday #37

I'm sorry that you don't care to engage with the subject seriously Orrex Sunday #38

This message was self-deleted by its author jfz9580m Monday #61

Oh staaahp, you relentless flirt! Orrex Monday #64

This message was self-deleted by its author jfz9580m Monday #65

I admire the courage of your convictions, willing to stand by your totally level-headed statements Orrex Monday #67

This message was self-deleted by its author jfz9580m Monday #68

Thank you and an excellent response. Biophilic Sunday #39

This message was self-deleted by its author jfz9580m Monday #60

And a lovely good morning to you as well? Orrex Monday #63

This message was self-deleted by its author jfz9580m Monday #66

Muslims: Bad press since The Crusades no_hypocrisy Sunday #4

Well, those and that little "conversion by the sword" thing. ColoringFool Sunday #5

What gets overlooked Old Crank Sunday #6

The Christian Crusaders butchered both Jews and Muslims. yardwork Sunday #12

And a lot of other Christians Old Crank Sunday #58

Not to mention a lot of women, pagans, so-called witches. yardwork Monday #62

THIS!!!!!!! eom BlueMTexpat Sunday #13

"Conversion by the sword" is a misconception/trope used against Muslims since the Middle Ages. AloeVera Sunday #16

Islamic people developed most of what we think of as modern advances. yardwork Sunday #22

I believe there is still a tremendous amount of guilt about what happened in WWII. Biophilic Sunday #7

it didnt start w ww2. mopinko Sunday #19

What didn't start with WWII? Biophilic Sunday #24

attacks on jews. mopinko Sunday #28

It's interesting, isn't it. yardwork Sunday #32

yup. mopinko Sunday #33

Oh, good grief, no. Like a couple of millennium. Biophilic Sunday #49

it mystifies me, too. mopinko Sunday #52

All I can do is agree with you. It's honestly a mystery. And Christianity never looks good. Biophilic Sunday #53

Most of what you've written here is inaccurate. yardwork Sunday #25

As I stated in my post these are the myths I grew up with. Myths! Not truths. Biophilic Sunday #43

So you don't agree with what you wrote above? yardwork Sunday #45

Many decades of conditioning, propaganda and manipulation have brought us here. OGBuzz Sunday #10

You can say that again. yardwork Sunday #14

You're saying it becase you imagine that it serves your agenda. Orrex Sunday #41

Seems like every country needs to have a focal point to hate BeneteauBum Sunday #15

Israel has plenty of reason to fear their neighbors. yardwork Sunday #17

Basically I agree with you BeneteauBum Sunday #40

I agree with this post. yardwork Sunday #46

For them, the end justifies the means. AloeVera Sunday #18

Are you quoting Hamas? yardwork Sunday #20

You can't just "disagree" with a genocide. AloeVera Sunday #42

I think that you and I have different personalities. yardwork Sunday #48

Don't be too sure of that! AloeVera Sunday #51

Not everyone BlueWaveNeverEnd Sunday #26

Its also American terrorism SSJVegeta Sunday #27

Bigotry, willful ignorance, cognitive dissonance, disingenuousness, motivated reasoning, etc. RockRaven Sunday #30

"Israel has plenty of reason to fear their neighbors." J_William_Ryan Sunday #34

What do you think would be an appropriate way TBF Sunday #50

Before the massacre, thousands of Palestinians were being held w/o charges, questionseverything Sunday #54

Nice evasion but I'm curious - who started the fire? TBF Sunday #55

so u believe everything u read in the nyt now? mopinko Sunday #56

There are pictures, there's victim testimony, there's ashamed Isreal guards testimony questionseverything Sunday #57

Nothing will be enough. AloeVera Sunday #59