Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

The Magistrate

(96,043 posts)
10. Attaining The Objective Is All Which 'Justifies' the Suffering Of War
Tue Aug 13, 2024, 07:43 PM
Aug 2024

No one starts a war without being of the view that the objective to be attained by it is worth the human and material cost of the attempt, and when war is commenced, each party to it signs a blank check drawn on the people and social material of both sides, payable in quantities of suffering to be filled in later by events. From the point of view of Hamas, killing or driving out the Jews of Israel seems worth any number of dead and maimed Palestinians: from the point of view of Israel, wrecking Hamas as an armed body seems worth any number of dead or maimed Palestinians. This is the reality of the situation, and it is that which shapes, and will continue to shape, its course.

Personally, I support only my country's present leadership. Should their view not accord with mine, that will alter neither my support for Mr. Biden's policies, nor my own views of the matter. It seems that the goal of our government's policy is to convince Arab powers in the region to eschew material support for Hamas, to cease turning a blind eye to its procurement of arms and otherwise tolerating, if not facilitating, its activities. One tool in this is the hostility between Iran, the chief sponsor of Hamas, and the Sunni states neighboring Israel. Another is the longstanding antipathy between Egypt's military and the old Moslem Brotherhood, from which Hamas sprang, and the longstanding dislike of the Jordanian monarchy for the bodies which are at the root of the Palestine Authority in the Jordan valley. I hope they succeed, diplomatic persuasion, and money, can be effective in achieving the goal of neutralizing an armed body dependent on the tolerance of established states.

But absent sufficient diplomatic and economic persuasion being brought to bear by neighboring states on Hamas, or the intervention of a military powerful enough to enforce its will on Israel, Israel will continue to attempt achievement of its objective in this war by military means.


"This is the best world possible everything in it is a necessary evil."






Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

When will enough killing be enough for wamonger Netanyahu? brush Aug 2024 #1
It's A Damn Shame Hamas Hasn't Freed Its Tortured Captives And Brought This To An End The Magistrate Aug 2024 #2
Honest question. Eko Aug 2024 #3
Honest answer. CincyDem Aug 2024 #4
I already know their answer. Eko Aug 2024 #5
My View Of That Is Irrelevant, Sir The Magistrate Aug 2024 #6
I certainly don't think your view is Irrelevant at all and that is why I asked. Eko Aug 2024 #7
The Numbers Game Has Pitfalls, Sir The Magistrate Aug 2024 #8
You keep telling me what hamas thinks. Eko Aug 2024 #9
Attaining The Objective Is All Which 'Justifies' the Suffering Of War The Magistrate Aug 2024 #10
That is a lot of words to say you are not going to answer the question. Eko Aug 2024 #11
You Just Don't Like The Answer The Magistrate Aug 2024 #12
You could have just been honest and said Eko Aug 2024 #13
But That Would Not Be An Honest Answer The Magistrate Aug 2024 #14
Are you at war? Eko Aug 2024 #15
Why? The Magistrate Aug 2024 #17
So you think russia is not morally wrong to have attacked Ukraine then? Eko Aug 2024 #16
I Know A Chief Objective Of the Nazis Was To Exterminate Jews The Magistrate Aug 2024 #18
I didnt ask mutliple people. Eko Aug 2024 #19
You Leave With What You Brought To The Conversation, No More And No Less The Magistrate Aug 2024 #20
You are so correct. Eko Aug 2024 #21
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Israel/Palestine»A Gazan father went to re...»Reply #10