Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

The Magistrate

(96,043 posts)
6. My View Of That Is Irrelevant, Sir
Tue Aug 13, 2024, 06:05 PM
Aug 2024

The government of Israel, and enough of its population to sustain the effort, are of the view that Hamas must be destroyed as an armed body capable of governance. I agree with that objective, and in fact fail to understand why anyone outside Hamas would urge an outcome which did leave Hamas capable of governing Gaza and conducting further attacks of any scale on Israel. Ceasefires simply kick the can down the road, and if Hamas emerges from this with any gain to show, a ceasefire guarantees repetition of what commenced this bout of bloodletting, and further Israeli military action in consequence. That those deaths wouldn't occur tomorrow, or next week, is something, certainly, but they will just be postponed, if things continue as usual in the longstanding conflict.

Hamas cannot preserve itself by military means; its sole weapon with any potential impact at all is the revulsion of people at the bystanders killed owing to their refusal to accept their circumstances. You might as well ask Sinwar how many dead Palestinians are enough to secure his objective of killing or driving out the Jews of Israel. It's a question worth asking. Would you consider surrender by Hamas an acceptable end to the killing? What do you think Hamas ought to do to end the killing?

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

When will enough killing be enough for wamonger Netanyahu? brush Aug 2024 #1
It's A Damn Shame Hamas Hasn't Freed Its Tortured Captives And Brought This To An End The Magistrate Aug 2024 #2
Honest question. Eko Aug 2024 #3
Honest answer. CincyDem Aug 2024 #4
I already know their answer. Eko Aug 2024 #5
My View Of That Is Irrelevant, Sir The Magistrate Aug 2024 #6
I certainly don't think your view is Irrelevant at all and that is why I asked. Eko Aug 2024 #7
The Numbers Game Has Pitfalls, Sir The Magistrate Aug 2024 #8
You keep telling me what hamas thinks. Eko Aug 2024 #9
Attaining The Objective Is All Which 'Justifies' the Suffering Of War The Magistrate Aug 2024 #10
That is a lot of words to say you are not going to answer the question. Eko Aug 2024 #11
You Just Don't Like The Answer The Magistrate Aug 2024 #12
You could have just been honest and said Eko Aug 2024 #13
But That Would Not Be An Honest Answer The Magistrate Aug 2024 #14
Are you at war? Eko Aug 2024 #15
Why? The Magistrate Aug 2024 #17
So you think russia is not morally wrong to have attacked Ukraine then? Eko Aug 2024 #16
I Know A Chief Objective Of the Nazis Was To Exterminate Jews The Magistrate Aug 2024 #18
I didnt ask mutliple people. Eko Aug 2024 #19
You Leave With What You Brought To The Conversation, No More And No Less The Magistrate Aug 2024 #20
You are so correct. Eko Aug 2024 #21
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Israel/Palestine»A Gazan father went to re...»Reply #6