Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

reACTIONary

(6,951 posts)
32. My point is that beers and smokes...
Tue Dec 9, 2025, 11:45 PM
Dec 9

... are not the same as ideas and talking to your friends about life. They are categorically different. So prohibiting kids from buying beer is not on point for prohibiting them from organizing a party on Facebook.

I am not against suicide prevention... I think it's great that they put nets up on the Golden Gate bridge. I'm all for help lines. But again, I think that is categorically different from banning kids from interacting with each other and learning more about the world.

Whether or not some specific group of parents are or are not "moral panickers," the fact of the matter is that such incidents and such groups can excite moral panics and that moral panics generally do not lead to reasoned deliberation and can be exploited by those who have, for want of a different characterization, illiberal intentions.

And I wonder why we don't hear more about kids who were diverted from suicide by engaging on social media. I know there are LBGQ+ kids who have been spared a lot of despair and loneliness by finding others like themselves on social media. Some have said they overcame suicidal ideation. There must be others besides them who have been helped by talking to a supportive community. But I guess if your kid doesn't commit suicide, you don't form a group and make everyone aware of it.

And, some of those illiberal parents who bully their LGBQ+ children who have found others online like them are all for a social media ban.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

What about TV, video, movies music etc. ok to buy a cd? Blues Heron Dec 9 #1
It doesn't affect anything but social media Violet_Crumble Dec 9 #12
Post removed Post removed Dec 9 #2
Well... that's just disappointing. Torchlight Dec 9 #3
Headline 2060: LudwigPastorius Dec 9 #4
Australia may become... littlemissmartypants Dec 9 #5
Just imagine... mysteryowl Dec 9 #6
The very same generation that isn't subject to mass school shootings groundloop Dec 9 #8
THIS orangecrush Dec 9 #10
They will certainly levelup their tech skills.... reACTIONary Dec 9 #19
This is the kind of work that can be done when there is a... reACTIONary Dec 9 #7
I disagree. It is only social media they are banned from. mysteryowl Dec 9 #9
Huh? Violet_Crumble Dec 9 #13
Then why are they banning kids from ... reACTIONary Dec 9 #16
There's been a spate of suicides here.. Violet_Crumble Dec 9 #21
My opinion is that... reACTIONary Dec 9 #26
Sneaky smokes and beers were a thing when I was a kid... Violet_Crumble Dec 9 #28
My point is that beers and smokes... reACTIONary Dec 9 #32
Ah! I see! It's an "only"! I guess an "only" oppression.... reACTIONary Dec 9 #17
I'm not a big fan of bans but if the evidence shows it works in those countries we should consider it. cstanleytech Dec 9 #11
Censorship, or other control of media is never good The Mouth Dec 9 #14
No limits on child porn? Violet_Crumble Dec 9 #23
That is evidence of a crime,. The Mouth Dec 10 #33
Wonder what happens when these teens become voting age? Polybius Dec 9 #15
I sure hope so.... reACTIONary Dec 9 #18
Some may, but in a really vague way. Violet_Crumble Dec 9 #25
From the article, an example of good, liberal parenting... reACTIONary Dec 9 #20
Its parents like him who are responsible for this in the first pkace Violet_Crumble Dec 9 #22
Its parents like this.... reACTIONary Dec 9 #24
Why are you referring to them as liberal when politics has nothing to do with it? Violet_Crumble Dec 9 #27
I beg your pardon. My son is not and never has been a bully.... reACTIONary Dec 9 #29
The biggest difference between America and Australia blubunyip Dec 9 #31
Well Done Australia OC375 Dec 9 #30
People praising Australia for this, yet when Texas banned porn sites for minors, they were generally ridiculed MichMan Dec 10 #34
True, that. Good observation. I bet ... reACTIONary Dec 10 #35
Hell, other than DU, I've banned social media from my own personal universe. hunter Dec 10 #36
I'll call it the MAP. moondust Dec 10 #37
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Millions of children and ...»Reply #32