General Discussion

lark

(25,913 posts)

74. I didn't know about the noise being possibly too loud.

Reply to EarlG (Reply #47)

Fri Jan 9, 2026, 05:25 PM

Jan 9

I'm still very suspicious.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

91 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Officer in Renee Good shooting fired the fatal shots while filming with a phone in his left hand [View all] EarlG Jan 9 OP

Noem's made for teevee execution UpInArms Jan 9 #1

Good questions, all of them. Maybe there might be answers--who knows? ...n/t CaliforniaPeggy Jan 9 #2

Only an idiot would film himself committing a crime GusBob Jan 9 #3

it backfired clevergrrrl Jan 9 #9

Or to show around to his other Brownshirt friends. Joinfortmill Jan 9 #61

Sick. greatauntoftriplets Jan 9 #4

What if...? ScoutHikerDad Jan 9 #5

The fact that he was holding his phone surely shows criminal negligence if nothing else EarlG Jan 9 #6

Standards and Legal FiveFifteen Jan 9 #80

It also makes it a harder to make the case that he was in fear for his life when he decided to pull the trigger. Ms. Toad Jan 9 #84

yes. Codifer Jan 9 #26

Im convinced that these ICE goons clevergrrrl Jan 9 #7

I think he screwed himself EarlG Jan 9 #11

I think I know what happened, it just came to me. clevergrrrl Jan 9 #13

Exactly. His distraction prevented him from knowing the car momentarily backed up. John1956PA Jan 9 #29

it's even worse uncle ray Jan 9 #50

You're right EarlG Jan 9 #53

you can see his hand in frame briefly when he is being confronted by Rebecca Good. uncle ray Jan 9 #54

Which is apparently what he calls her mcar Jan 9 #81

He filmed himself committing a murder. Joinfortmill Jan 9 #63

If nothing else genxlib Jan 9 #8

What the hell. 😡😡 TommieMommy Jan 9 #10

He was told to film the interactions clevergrrrl Jan 9 #12

Trophy hunting is psycho/serial killer behavior, and evidence of premeditation. RockRaven Jan 9 #14

Her last words Autumn Jan 9 #15

He needs the Death Penalty. Joinfortmill Jan 9 #66

Chilling mcar Jan 9 #82

"Out here shootin' libtards, now smash that LIKE button! Don't forget to subscribe!" flvegan Jan 9 #16

Now they're doing snuff films. Scrivener7 Jan 9 #17

That's how the Abu Ghraib story broke DBoon Jan 9 #27

Jeezus. Humans need a reboot. Joinfortmill Jan 9 #68

That was my first impression as well PatSeg Jan 9 #32

That was my take on it. Lifeafter70 Jan 9 #36

Making a snuff video. drray23 Jan 9 #18

Here's the video. 17 seconds. Totally unnecessary underpants Jan 9 #19

+1 dalton99a Jan 9 #24

Renee Nicole Good: "That's fine dude, I'm not mad at you." ICE Officer: "Fuckin' bitch" underpants Jan 9 #20

He can be heard calling her a "f***ing b****" immediately after shooting her. PA Democrat Jan 9 #21

He may have been live live streaming on Facebook. John1956PA Jan 9 #22

No, they released this themselves, on purpose EarlG Jan 9 #25

It makes him look even worse MustLoveBeagles Jan 9 #33

I disagree but I guess I'll be the only one here to. Callie1979 Jan 9 #38

Why they released it, IMO dpibel Jan 9 #69

Yes! I think he was livestreaming it! EarthAbides Jan 9 #34

So he made sure he was filming, and bumps into the car orangecrush Jan 9 #65

Exactly. She's turning the steering wheel to avoid the dumbass who is filming her. Rhiagel Jan 9 #70

Kick dalton99a Jan 9 #23

Great evidence of his malice. nt SunSeeker Jan 9 #28

More and more convinced that this was a planned and provoked shooting Prairie Gates Jan 9 #30

They are proud of killing people. And maybe they get a bonus for every dead body. Irish_Dem Jan 9 #31

Trophy hunters who can't afford safaris or those stateside 'wild animal' hunt parks for rich guys? Attilatheblond Jan 9 #39

Exactly. Poor man's version of human safaris. Irish_Dem Jan 9 #46

Oh yeah..... SergeStorms Jan 9 #35

I noticed it too, but thought 'nah, they can't be that stupid, maybe just a bad view angle' Attilatheblond Jan 9 #42

Using Palantir cellphone facial recognition app? orangecrush Jan 9 #37

Pix are for creation of a database of "domestic terrorists" duckworth969 Jan 9 #51

What I was thinking orangecrush Jan 9 #64

So she was dead when the car moved toward him. Srkdqltr Jan 9 #40

The video released from his phone is fake!!! lark Jan 9 #41

I agree! See my post below! Silver Gaia Jan 9 #45

The fact that this video was clearly released in coordination with the White House is certainly grounds for suspicion EarlG Jan 9 #47

I am still suspicious. Silver Gaia Jan 9 #52

I didn't know about the noise being possibly too loud. lark Jan 9 #74

This message was self-deleted by its author jeffreyi Jan 9 #43

All I see is that she was clearly the calmer person in that situation, Silver Gaia Jan 9 #44

He could have fired because for a split second he THOUGHT he was going to get hit, but EarlG Jan 9 #49

Thanks for your response, EarlG. Silver Gaia Jan 9 #57

The "accelerating" stuff is driving me crazy! Pacifist Patriot Jan 9 #48

Did she accelerate before she was shot in the head? markodochartaigh Jan 9 #56

That's what I think... Silver Gaia Jan 9 #58

My thinking as well. yellow dahlia Jan 10 #89

Yes. But think of it in terms of parallel parking. You both Pacifist Patriot Jan 9 #83

The car shot forward after she was shot. yellow dahlia Jan 10 #88

ICE can access the phones of any person onsite of a protest duckworth969 Jan 9 #55

This is what ends Trump's presidency. Joinfortmill Jan 9 #59

One hopes 🤞 MustLoveBeagles Jan 9 #67

Amen. Joinfortmill Jan 9 #71

TOTALLY AGAINST PROCEDURE, per ex-ICE supervisor on MS-NOW this afternoon. Paladin Jan 9 #60

That could end up being the key to this EarlG Jan 9 #72

You need two hands to control any high caliber automatic... farmbo Jan 9 #76

It is contrary to all practices and training with regards to guns. yellow dahlia Jan 10 #90

Distracted attention in public moondust Jan 9 #62

My guess is that it is for Bettie Jan 9 #73

My question is, why would anyone in this situation walk as close as possible in front of a car? flashman13 Jan 9 #75

After seeing this video and the enhancement on CNN hamsterjill Jan 9 #86

If your theory is correct that would definitely indicate premeditation. I suppose sufficient premeditation could occur flashman13 Jan 9 #87

Does MN have a law against driving distracted (mobile device)? FiveFifteen Jan 9 #77

It seems odd that he released that video, it doc03 Jan 9 #78

I agree. I have thought Vance wanted to get ahead of the curve. John1956PA Jan 9 #79

Post removed Post removed Jan 9 #85

He started recording with the phone in his right hand MurrayDelph Jan 10 #91