Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Archae

(46,892 posts)
Tue Apr 11, 2023, 06:50 AM Apr 2023

Has anyone else noticed how badly the anti-GMO "crusade" has burned out?

This guy is still active though, AFAIK.

In fact when face with (OMG!) actual scientific EVIDENCE, he goes straight to a really juvenile insult.

http://americanloons.blogspot.com/2023/04/2636-tami-canal.html

22 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Has anyone else noticed how badly the anti-GMO "crusade" has burned out? (Original Post) Archae Apr 2023 OP
you can definitely change your DNA through diet- not sure where they came up with that Blues Heron Apr 2023 #1
Glyphosate has been proven to change one's DNA, gab13by13 Apr 2023 #2
In the words of the old saying, "They saw you coming." Archae Apr 2023 #4
I never would dream of trying to change your opinion gab13by13 Apr 2023 #5
Good to hear abut the arrangement your daughter has. Archae Apr 2023 #7
If you want to reduce pesticide use, GMO is the way to go. progressoid Apr 2023 #16
I still remember clearly a local news interview with a local anti_GMO activist... Archae Apr 2023 #3
There is no debate that glyphosate is a carcinogen. gab13by13 Apr 2023 #6
The point is ANYTHING can be a carcinogen. Archae Apr 2023 #8
I'm really going out of my way trying not to upset you, gab13by13 Apr 2023 #10
So because a movement is growing, that means it is correct? progressoid Apr 2023 #17
Hasn't all the anti-GMO energy been sucked into the anti-vax "movement"? n/t xocetaceans Apr 2023 #9
That statement has me confused. gab13by13 Apr 2023 #11
That's good to hear... Archae Apr 2023 #12
enjoy getting disease because the anti gmo people told ya so reymega life Apr 2023 #13
What? Archae Apr 2023 #14
True believers are the worst Warpy Apr 2023 #15
Yeah all it takes is another Oprah to start up another wave of nonsense. progressoid Apr 2023 #18
Or some televangelist with new people it's OK to hate Warpy Apr 2023 #19
Yep. progressoid Apr 2023 #20
I am anti-GMO edhopper May 2023 #21
Yes WestMichRad Jun 2023 #22

Blues Heron

(6,228 posts)
1. you can definitely change your DNA through diet- not sure where they came up with that
Tue Apr 11, 2023, 07:07 AM
Apr 2023

" It should be unnecessary to point out that you cannot change your DNA through diet. "

If only that were true.


its called cancer which is a mutation in your DNA and you can definitely get it through diet.

gab13by13

(25,400 posts)
2. Glyphosate has been proven to change one's DNA,
Tue Apr 11, 2023, 07:19 AM
Apr 2023

and is also a carcinogen.

I choose to eat organic food, it doesn't guarantee that I'm not eating pesticides or RoundUp but my odds are better. I also found that organic foods taste so much better, I will always drink organic milk, and eat organic fruits.

Look how many states and countries have banned RoundUP;

I had to delete my link because at the end there was a law firm to contact. I will find another link. Suffice it to say that many countries, states, cities, are banning Roundup.

Try this test at home folks; Put a GMO potato in a glass of water, then put an organic potato in a glass of water and see what happens.

Archae

(46,892 posts)
4. In the words of the old saying, "They saw you coming."
Tue Apr 11, 2023, 07:33 AM
Apr 2023

Yes, I am saying you were suckered by the anti-GMO hysterics and con artists.

If you want to eat organic, fine.

Just quit giving people like myself who don't want to spend such a high price at Whole Foods the stink-eye.

gab13by13

(25,400 posts)
5. I never would dream of trying to change your opinion
Tue Apr 11, 2023, 07:41 AM
Apr 2023

or tell you what to eat, it's none of my business.

Here is an article that gives both sides of studies of glyphosate;

https://www.popsci.com/health/glyphosate-round-up-epa-ban/

Try the potato test.

Actually, I think the price of organic foods is getting closer to the price of GMO foods. One can also buy from local farms who don't use Roundup. My daughter lives outside of Pittsburgh and she buys from local farms that even deliver her food to her doorstep. Daughter even makes a tasty organic pizza.

Archae

(46,892 posts)
7. Good to hear abut the arrangement your daughter has.
Tue Apr 11, 2023, 07:47 AM
Apr 2023

Last time I was at our local "Pick and Save," I noticed that organic sausages in the organic aisle cost twice as much.

And the facts are very simple, organic producers are not a bunch of hippie farmers singing to plants as they tenderly water them.

Organic producer are just as mechanized, as other farmers, and they use some really nasty chemical fertilizers, and pesticides.

progressoid

(50,787 posts)
16. If you want to reduce pesticide use, GMO is the way to go.
Tue Apr 11, 2023, 12:28 PM
Apr 2023
Phytophthora infestans, the fungus-like causal organism of potato blight, can rapidly destroy potato crops and regularly causes significant losses to potato farmers worldwide. To control this disease, growers commonly resort to spraying their crops with fungicides on a near weekly basis.


The susceptible potato variety and the two resistant ones (GMO) were cultivated comparing common practice, with fungicides applied on a weekly basis, and the IPM2.0 method. The research was carried out in the Netherlands and in Ireland, two prominent potato countries, over several years.

The IPM2.0 strategy on the susceptible variety Désirée, resulted in an average reduction of 15% on the fungicide input. Both resistant varieties however remained healthy with an average 80 to 90% reduction of the fungicide input.

The internationally recognised and publicly available Environmental Yardstick for Pesticides was used to quantify the environmental impact. It quantifies the environmental impact of chemical crop protection on water-life, soil-life and groundwater.



Susceptible variety Désirée cultivated under common practice annually received an average of over 700 environmental impact points. Désirée cultivated under IPM2.0 reduced this score to some 400 points.

Both resistant varieties however scored much better under IPM2.0: cultivation of Sarpo Mira received an annual average of only 40 points, while the cisgenic resistant version of Désirée scored even better, less than ten points.


https://www.wur.nl/en/news-wur/Show/More-sustainable-potato-production-through-extended-IPM-for-late-blight.htm



Also, if you are worried about carcinogens then perhaps you should be eating GMO potatoes. The new varieties actually reduce the amount of the amino acid asparagine that turns into acrylamide, a probable human carcinogen, that occurs when potatoes are cooked at high temperatures. So that's good right?



Finally...the GMO potato in water test. What exactly does this test prove?

Archae

(46,892 posts)
3. I still remember clearly a local news interview with a local anti_GMO activist...
Tue Apr 11, 2023, 07:30 AM
Apr 2023

She was doing it "for her kids" to stop any cancers she hoped they never got.

And she smoked through whole interview.

Guess what! LIFE causes cancer.

gab13by13

(25,400 posts)
6. There is no debate that glyphosate is a carcinogen.
Tue Apr 11, 2023, 07:44 AM
Apr 2023

We know that Roundup has glyphosate in it but we don't even know everything else that is in Roundup, all of the ingredients are a trade secret.

gab13by13

(25,400 posts)
10. I'm really going out of my way trying not to upset you,
Tue Apr 11, 2023, 08:19 AM
Apr 2023

but the facts are that the anti-glyphosate "movement" is not dying out, it is growing. I just read where Germany is banning Roundup in 2024. I can show you the list of countries and states and cities that have banned Roundup.

Yes, one can get cancer from many things, but if glyphosate weakens one's immune system that person is going to be more susceptible to getting cancer.

Do you know why scientists don't do studies with human subjects to compare GMO v non-GMO? Why do they only do studies using mice?

progressoid

(50,787 posts)
17. So because a movement is growing, that means it is correct?
Tue Apr 11, 2023, 01:25 PM
Apr 2023

Yes, glyphosate is harmful. Like any chemical, the dosage makes the poison.

Speaking of...

"Organic" doesn't preclude it from being sprayed with chemicals. In fact many aren't even organic. But the industry still gets to use these "organic" chemicals. (It's kind of a long list)


In addition to those chemicals (some which are synthetic), a number of organic farmers are even asking the federal government for permission to use more synthetic pesticides.

gab13by13

(25,400 posts)
11. That statement has me confused.
Tue Apr 11, 2023, 08:22 AM
Apr 2023

I am slow, can you explain it to me? I am definitely pro-vax. I had to get immunized to travel to foreign countries for my job or I could quit.

Archae

(46,892 posts)
12. That's good to hear...
Tue Apr 11, 2023, 09:16 AM
Apr 2023

But did you read ALL of the posted article?

It states flat out this big-time anti-GMO guru and his groupies are stridently anti-vaxx.

In fact, they believe in "chemtrails," "Morgellon's disease," etc. in addition to their anti-GMO hysterics.

Warpy

(113,131 posts)
15. True believers are the worst
Tue Apr 11, 2023, 11:42 AM
Apr 2023

because what passes for a personality is completely submerged into that belief. There's not much you can do about that, they simply will not allow the conversation to be steered elsewhere.

The anti GMO fanatics ran out of gas because people who didn't give a shit kept eating GMO foods and didn't get sick. That took a lot of wind out of their sails. Had they focused on the inability of farmers to hold seed over for the next year, they might have gotten farther as far as longevity goes, but people tune out when ag and patent policies get discussed. The audience would have been smaller, but at least they'd still have one.

Warpy

(113,131 posts)
19. Or some televangelist with new people it's OK to hate
Tue Apr 11, 2023, 04:15 PM
Apr 2023

Or some starlet with a new diet

Or some faded starlet with a line of crap that no thinking woman would ever consider

Or some life extension hack with a new bunch of supplements

Or some manly man with a homoerotic exercise routine

And the list goes on and on.

progressoid

(50,787 posts)
20. Yep.
Wed Apr 12, 2023, 01:48 AM
Apr 2023

And while the internet can do all sorts of wonderful things, it also feeds these whackos.

edhopper

(35,041 posts)
21. I am anti-GMO
Mon May 8, 2023, 09:12 AM
May 2023

not because it is inherently bad, but because it allows large corporations to take complete control over the food supply by claiming ownership of everything grown or raised. There needs to be legislation to protect food producers from this.

Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Skepticism, Science & Pseudoscience»Has anyone else noticed h...