Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

question everything

(49,073 posts)
Tue Dec 24, 2024, 12:00 AM 19 hrs ago

Has anyone heard about lightning all 8 candles on the first night, then 7 and finally just one

on the last night? Someone mentioned that during one of the stories about Hanukkah these days.

9 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Has anyone heard about lightning all 8 candles on the first night, then 7 and finally just one (Original Post) question everything 19 hrs ago OP
Nope, haven't heard it. elleng 18 hrs ago #1
Just saw it on Facebook yesterday. Bluebelle76 16 hrs ago #2
Found More Bluebelle76 15 hrs ago #3
Thank you for taking the time to search. It was Rabbi Shammai whose approach was more rigid question everything 8 hrs ago #6
I usually prefer Hillel's positions Mossfern 7 hrs ago #8
This message was self-deleted by its author Bluebelle76 15 hrs ago #4
The children love it, but the older people don't. Irish_Dem 10 hrs ago #5
Just to cover your bases Mosby 7 hrs ago #7
What a great idea. Irish_Dem 6 hrs ago #9

Bluebelle76

(11 posts)
2. Just saw it on Facebook yesterday.
Tue Dec 24, 2024, 03:43 AM
16 hrs ago

I'm not Jewish, so generic info only. That light display was suggested some time ago. I can see the symbolism. It would be a reliving of what happened so long ago. Quite a lesson for children.

A famous rabbi (maybe Hillel?) said that it's a more inspiring symbol for the light to grow over time. Those weren't the words used, but I think it kind of gets the gist. Maybe he wanted to express the awe of what happened.

Anyway, everyone followed the advice of the rabbi.

Please let me know if anyone finds the name of the famous rabbi. I'm not great at searching Facebook.

Bluebelle76

(11 posts)
3. Found More
Tue Dec 24, 2024, 03:59 AM
15 hrs ago

I found more info on Judaicapedia.org. It was a discussion/debate between Hillel and Shabbai. Hillel maintained that holiness should always increase. So the lights should increase.

Mossfern

(3,247 posts)
8. I usually prefer Hillel's positions
Tue Dec 24, 2024, 12:44 PM
7 hrs ago

over Shammai and I agree with lighting one more candle each night.

Response to Bluebelle76 (Reply #2)

Irish_Dem

(59,638 posts)
5. The children love it, but the older people don't.
Tue Dec 24, 2024, 09:09 AM
10 hrs ago

I am in a blended family of different religions and ethnicities.
Raised Catholic but attended synagogue as an adult, with some of my married in family.

The children have always wanted to light all the menorah candles at home on the first night of Hanukka.
The adults refused and did it the traditional way.

But last year the adults relented and lit the whole shebang first night.
I was somewhat horrified and threatened to rat out the whole lot of them to the Rabbi.
They all laughed because the rabbi is Reform, very laid back and would be glad that we
lit the candles and said our prayers and brought Jewish tradition Ito the home.

So I guess we will do the same this year too.

Mosby

(17,634 posts)
7. Just to cover your bases
Tue Dec 24, 2024, 12:07 PM
7 hrs ago

You could light several menorahs different ways, one per Hillel and one per Shammai.

When I was a kid we had the large family one and me and my sisters had our own little ones we got in Israel. Mine is a replica of the one outside the Knesset.

Irish_Dem

(59,638 posts)
9. What a great idea.
Tue Dec 24, 2024, 01:05 PM
6 hrs ago

Everyone will be happy then.
And I don't have to call the rabbi crisis line.

Oh that is neat about the little ones for the kids.
One of the kids in my family was bat mitzvahed in Israel so we use one she got at that time.

Latest Discussions»Alliance Forums»Jewish Group»Has anyone heard about li...