Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

Taverner

(55,476 posts)
Tue Dec 13, 2011, 09:20 PM Dec 2011

Question for the group: Could you be an Atheist Christian?

I mean conceivably, say you do not believe in god but like Jesus. Say, just wanting to emulate certain aspects of him - whether fictional or true.

Would this not define a Christian more than mere theism?

A Marxist does not think Marx was god.

An Augustinian does not think St Augustine was god.

A Jungian does not think Carl Jung was god.

So why would it be so important that a Christian believes that Christ is god?

Considering he never said he was, in any of the canonical gospels.

32 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Question for the group: Could you be an Atheist Christian? (Original Post) Taverner Dec 2011 OP
Yes, I am an 'Atheist Christian'...as Gandhi quoted..... 1620rock Dec 2011 #1
I like that Taverner Dec 2011 #2
Is there any verified proof that Gahdhi ever said that? Common Sense Party Feb 2012 #19
I would consider you an agnostic. A person who doesn't know for sure wheter there is a god or not. southernyankeebelle Dec 2011 #3
I don't give a rat's ass if there is a god or not... Taverner Dec 2011 #6
Post removed Post removed Dec 2011 #10
Sorry - not the best wording or way of saying it Taverner Dec 2011 #13
Well, that certainly moved the discussion along... timtom Dec 2011 #12
Taverner--why are you posting here? Thats my opinion Mar 2012 #29
Why are you responding? Taverner May 2012 #32
I don't believe in God and consider myself a Christian. justgamma Dec 2011 #4
I second your comment. I feel the same. southernyankeebelle Dec 2011 #11
Sounds a lot like the Jefferson bible, actually WildEyedLiberal Dec 2011 #5
No, that'd make you a Jesuist ButterflyBlood Dec 2011 #7
I thought atheist christianity is called humanism Betty Karlson Dec 2011 #8
Not if the humanism is derived specifically from New Testament ethics Bucky Dec 2011 #14
Well, Jesus taught us we're all God's children Betty Karlson Dec 2011 #16
Isn't that close to UU's? sweetloukillbot Dec 2011 #15
UUism welcomes a broad range of theistic and atheistic views deutsey Feb 2012 #25
I consider myself a Christ theologian Thats my opinion Dec 2011 #9
Where is your book available, Tmo? I'd be interested. Thx. nt Critters2 Dec 2011 #18
try Amazon.com nt Thats my opinion Feb 2012 #20
As a Girardian Christian, I'm pretty close to that. nt Critters2 Dec 2011 #17
Unless you are trolling in someone else's water, thisw belongs in "religion." nt Thats my opinion Feb 2012 #21
This is what a "safe haven" looks like on DU3. nt Union Scribe Feb 2012 #22
I don't think so. Tripod Feb 2012 #23
An Atheist Christian is a contradiction in terms. Kurmudgeon Feb 2012 #24
Remember supernova Mar 2012 #26
Great topic.... BB_Troll Mar 2012 #28
Guess it depends on your definition of belief. 54anickel May 2012 #30
Wasn't this issue settled at the Councils of Nice? nt Joseph8th Mar 2012 #27
The Answer is . . . azmaximillian May 2012 #31

1620rock

(2,218 posts)
1. Yes, I am an 'Atheist Christian'...as Gandhi quoted.....
Tue Dec 13, 2011, 09:27 PM
Dec 2011

"I like your Christ. I do not like your Christians."

Common Sense Party

(14,139 posts)
19. Is there any verified proof that Gahdhi ever said that?
Thu Feb 9, 2012, 11:49 AM
Feb 2012

I know it's attributed to him all over the internets, but I'm not sure he ever said that.

 

southernyankeebelle

(11,304 posts)
3. I would consider you an agnostic. A person who doesn't know for sure wheter there is a god or not.
Tue Dec 13, 2011, 09:36 PM
Dec 2011
 

Taverner

(55,476 posts)
6. I don't give a rat's ass if there is a god or not...
Tue Dec 13, 2011, 10:59 PM
Dec 2011

All I know is there is a dog

Her name is 'Betty'

And she's a good dog

Dogs are superior to gods...

Response to Taverner (Reply #6)

Thats my opinion

(2,001 posts)
29. Taverner--why are you posting here?
Fri Mar 30, 2012, 12:33 PM
Mar 2012

Isn't that called trolling in someone else's water? Go home.

justgamma

(3,679 posts)
4. I don't believe in God and consider myself a Christian.
Tue Dec 13, 2011, 10:03 PM
Dec 2011

I believe in Jesus and his teachings. I know that I could never believe in the wingers version of God.

WildEyedLiberal

(12,799 posts)
5. Sounds a lot like the Jefferson bible, actually
Tue Dec 13, 2011, 10:06 PM
Dec 2011

I believe he removed all the 'miraculous' aspects of the Gospels and left intact all of Jesus's teachings.

ETA: Jefferson was a deist, so he believed in a creator God of some power, but I do not believe he was a Christian in the sense that he believed one needed to belong to a Christian church. He was certainly a Christian in your sense of the word, though.

ButterflyBlood

(12,644 posts)
7. No, that'd make you a Jesuist
Wed Dec 14, 2011, 12:39 AM
Dec 2011
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jesuism

There's a separate category for this. And remember that the word "Christ" means "Savior", so if one believes Jesus was just a man the term is meaningless, and thus "Christian" is as well. Jesuist makes sense, but Christian does not.

Of course you could most certainly be a "cultural Christian" as I'm sure most atheists in the US are, similar to atheist Jews. One guy at my work made a comment about how he needs Christmas Eve off (we are open then but close early) because he's doing a duet with his sister at church. His Facebook contains references to the Flying Spaghetti Monster and I know he is at most an agnostic.
 

Betty Karlson

(7,231 posts)
8. I thought atheist christianity is called humanism
Wed Dec 14, 2011, 10:17 AM
Dec 2011

But organised humanism can be just as conceited and intolerant as organised christianity.

Bucky

(55,334 posts)
14. Not if the humanism is derived specifically from New Testament ethics
Thu Dec 15, 2011, 05:42 PM
Dec 2011

If you anchor your ethics in Jesus's teachings, it'd be entirely appropriate to call yourself Christian, even if you don't buy into the cosmology of salvation and heaven and whatnot. Of course it might be less confusing if such people called themselves "Jesusites" or something, but the Jesuits kind of cornered that market already.

 

Betty Karlson

(7,231 posts)
16. Well, Jesus taught us we're all God's children
Fri Dec 16, 2011, 05:57 AM
Dec 2011

That would include himself - He showed us how to be a child of God. To detach those ethics from the connection with God, to sever that connection, is not very Christian: because it takes away from Jesus' message.

He once summerised his teachings as: Love your neighbour as you love yourself, and love God with all your heart, all your strength, all your wisdom. You can't just abbreviate that to "love the neighbour as you love yourself".

To take God out of Christ's teachings is like taking the vegetables out of your next meal: no doubt it's still palatable, but it's not the same anymore - and certainly not as healthy as it used to be.

deutsey

(20,166 posts)
25. UUism welcomes a broad range of theistic and atheistic views
Wed Feb 29, 2012, 12:19 PM
Feb 2012

UU Christians are a minority in UUism for the most part (which is ironic, considering Unitarianism and Universalism both began as liberal Christian movements), but they're out there. King's Chapel in Boston, I believe, is Unitarian and very Christian.

The UU fellowship I attend has a mixture of humanists, people attracted to Eastern philosophies, some Christians, atheists, a couple New Age types, many who are seeking. They're mostly politically liberal, but there are theologically open-minded political conservatives who attend as well.

Although all UU denominations in the UUA adhere to the 7 Principles (http://www.uua.org/beliefs/principles/index.shtml), the democratic process is a big part of UUism so it's up to the members of each church/congregation/fellowship to determine the prevailing ethos of their community.

Thats my opinion

(2,001 posts)
9. I consider myself a Christ theologian
Wed Dec 14, 2011, 02:21 PM
Dec 2011

To say Jesus is God is the wrong question with the wrong answer for many thoughtful people.

In my book "Building an Biblical Faith," I put it this way "Jesus is all of God we can see or imagine in human form."

 

Kurmudgeon

(1,751 posts)
24. An Atheist Christian is a contradiction in terms.
Thu Feb 23, 2012, 12:29 AM
Feb 2012

John 11:25 "Jesus said unto her, I am the resurrection, and the life: he that believeth in me, though he were dead, yet shall he live:"

And that isn't even counting all the times He prayed to God directly.
He wouldn't have done that if He didn't expect, didn't KNOW that God was there.

If you are a Christian, then you believe fully what Jesus Christ preached.
You can respect or honor Christ and not be a Christian.
However, you can't be a Christian if you don't believe fully what Jesus Christ said.
You believe or you don't, there's no half way.

supernova

(39,345 posts)
26. Remember
Thu Mar 1, 2012, 11:33 AM
Mar 2012

this is a group for liberal xtians, both in terms of theology and politics.

The Christian community is all over the map when it comes to what individuals believe about the Resurrection. You are going to get a variety of answers on that subject even here. Me for example, I'm agnostic, at best, on the subject of the Resurrection.

BB_Troll

(65 posts)
28. Great topic....
Thu Mar 29, 2012, 03:28 PM
Mar 2012

Jesus did claim to be God and claimed to be the expected Messiah. Did he lie about that?

54anickel

(22,453 posts)
30. Guess it depends on your definition of belief.
Sat May 5, 2012, 02:55 PM
May 2012

The etomology of the word believe is facinating in and of itself. Prior to the enlightment you "believed" in a person. Meaning you trusted, had faith in that person. The root of the word believe is beloved.
Now we relate the notion of belief not in a person, but in statements. It has been narrowed into belief in a statement as being true or false. Quite different than "believing" in a person to be loving, trustworthy, honorable.

 

azmaximillian

(14 posts)
31. The Answer is . . .
Tue May 8, 2012, 12:19 PM
May 2012

No, The word Christian has a traditional and historic meaning. I respect your right to believe as you wish. But we need to have a language with meanings.

Latest Discussions»Alliance Forums»Christian Liberals & Progressive People of Faith»Question for the group: C...