English must be so confusing to ESL people - where is the 'g' in anxiety?
Surely there are other anomalies. But I was wondering about this one last night.
intrepidity
(7,926 posts)And sometimes it's invisible, as in anxiety.
ret5hd
(21,320 posts)intrepidity
(7,926 posts)Haggard Celine
(17,044 posts)Glorfindel
(9,958 posts)Love your new user name!
Haggard Celine
(17,044 posts)I guess she thinks she looks good. Sad. No, autocorrect messed up my name when I put it in and I am stuck with this name for a few years, I guess. It's supposed to be Hagbard Celine, after the character in some Robert Anton Wilson novels. I guess people are going to think I'm making fun of Celine Dion now, and that is unfortunate.
Glorfindel
(9,958 posts)g and a z. Also, the "wh" words are confusing. Half of English speakers pronounce them with a silent "h," as in "were" for "where" and "wen" for "when." The other half pronounce them as "hw" words, as in "hwere" and "hwen." Learning English would definitely be hard!
ret5hd
(21,320 posts)Glorfindel
(9,958 posts)Very cute.
We were talking about Wil Wheaton at work the other day and I kept pronouncing like that just to annoy my coworker.
Warpy
(113,131 posts)Come to think of it, everything about that creature made me clench my teeth, and that was before the Russians greased him into office.
Buckeye_Democrat
(15,069 posts)Yeah, "anxiety" isn't very phonetic, is it?
2naSalit
(93,435 posts)There is a phenomena that occurs for people for whom English is not their primary language where they insert incorrect letters due to their internal etymology where they see they root of the word anxiety being included in the root for anger or angst, thus they insert it thinking that is the likely spelling of a word they may never have seen in written form.
I did a bit of proofreading for ESL students in college and found several patterns of incorrect spellings based on that reasoning. They really work hard to get it right with our very messy language.
TxGuitar
(4,281 posts)Saw that on FB recently
Buckeye_Democrat
(15,069 posts)bucolic_frolic
(47,572 posts)It will be a great tune!
2naSalit
(93,435 posts)I had that very thought and I think I might have to write a bluegrass tune about that.
bucolic_frolic
(47,572 posts)But even the most popular bank, I think I read, about 1 cent per 10 clicks.
But there are YouTubers making $55k per month! Or so they say ...
So if you can do it, get in that hampster wheel and run!
(Note to Admins ... we so need a smiley of a hamster wheel!)
Warpy
(113,131 posts)with a limited vocabulary because most nouns don't have gender and there are no modifiers or declensions to note their places in a sentence. Most if it is Franco-Germanic/Viking very loosely strung on a Celtic framework. There are a lot of analogues to other European languages, making it easier to understand for European visitors.
The bugger is learning to speak it well.
(By the way, I pronounce it anks EYE uh tee, that's upper Midwest, upstate NY, and New England talking)
Buckeye_Democrat
(15,069 posts)The 'g' reference confused me at first, but I later realized some people pronounce it a little differently.
NCjack
(10,297 posts)when my wife told me to "knock myself out."
2naSalit
(93,435 posts)I learned to speak in northern New England so I had French and English exposure full time along with snippets if many other languages at public schools.
I have discovered, while proof reading college papers for ESL and foreign students, that they often try to equate similar sounding words and go for it when choosing a letter such as "G" for anxiety, especially if they never saw it in written form prior. Your description of Modern English is the most succinct I have ever seen yet our English is still very messy.
PoindexterOglethorpe
(26,840 posts)One is that we have an awful lot of words we've "borrowed" from other languages. Which means the spelling may remain what it was in the other language.
Another is that pronunciation has changed over time.
A third is that a lot of our spelling was standardized at least 200 years ago, an the spelling and pronunciation no longer match up.
Every time someone suggests we switch to a purely phonetic spelling in English, I roll my eyes, because there would be various spellings of a lot of words, and some of them might be incomprehensible to many of us.
Shermann
(8,722 posts)Successful empires like Britain tended to absorb a lot of the culture of those they conquered.
2naSalit
(93,435 posts)The close to 1/3rd of English being French derived is due to the French owning England for a time as well.
Shermann
(8,722 posts)Too easy.
2naSalit
(93,435 posts)Trying to read text from the 17th and 18th even 19th centuries can be mind bending and distracting.
Martin68
(24,726 posts)I taught English as a second language in Japan for 20 years, so I sympathize with people who have to learn English as an adult. Perhaps the most famous is the one that George Bernard Shaw like to point out. "Ghoti" is another way to spell the word "fish" if you use the "gh" in "enough", the "o" in "women", and the "ti" in "nation." A lot of the confusion in English is that the language is a Germanic language that took on a lot of Latin characteristics while France ruled England. One result of French rule is that words for domestic animals usually derive from the Anglo-Saxon words the peasant farmers used, and words for the food made from those animals used the French words that the ruling class used. Beef for the food and cattle for the animal, Pork for the food and pig for the animal and so on.