Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

beac

(9,992 posts)
Tue Jan 3, 2012, 04:38 PM Jan 2012

Gin is better than rubbing alcohol.

Before you worry that I've gone off the deep end in search of a cut-rate martini, this post is a follow-up to mine on DU2 about using alcohol to stunt the growth of paperwhites and thus prevent toppling over.

The link I originally posted on DU2 suffered from having the WRONG kind of flower in the accompanying picture but, once I really started researching this, I found all the info links back to a study done at Cornell University. (http://blogs.cornell.edu/hort/2009/11/10/pickling-your-paperwhites)

I planted a "control" batch in water, a batch in a water/rubbing alcohol mix and a batch in a water/gin mix.

See the Cornell article for the details but, in a nutshell, the ratios are ten-or-eleven-to-one water-to-rubbing alcohol and eight-to-one water-to-gin (or any other 80-proof liquor, I just had leftover gin from a party.)

Per the instructions, I started all the paperwhites in water and when the roots were a couple of inches long, I poured out the water and replaced it with the alcohol-water mix and continued to water with that mix for the life of the plant.


The water and RA plants were planted about a week earlier than the gins, but all are full grown. I put books under some so that the bulbs would all be at the same height.



The water plants needing typing up well before Christmans and keeled over again just minutes before the photoshoot. In truth, the door is propping them up.

As you can see, the RA barely stunted growth at all and those plants still needed to be tied together to prevent toppling. I used an 11-to-1 ratio, so perhaps the 10-to-one ratio would have worked better. I also got more yellowing earlier in the tips of the RA plants.

The gin really worked. Anywhere from 25-65% shorter plants.

The flowers, fragrance and everything else was the same across all plants.

I am starting a new batch of 6 bulbs in one planter with gin to see if the fact that the gin bulbs were singles/pairs impacted the results at all. Also doing some pairs in RA. Will post a pic of these when they are grown.

(Picked up second round of bulbs at an end-of-season sale. They were marked 60% off and the manager gave me two-for-one on top of that-- 24 bulbs for just under $5. Hurray for bargain experiments! )

20 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies

badhair77

(4,665 posts)
1. interesting
Tue Jan 3, 2012, 06:51 PM
Jan 2012

We can use all the blooming we can get with this newly-cold winter. Thanks for the info.

beac

(9,992 posts)
2. You're welcome. Paperwhites help with my winter gardening DTs.
Tue Jan 3, 2012, 07:30 PM
Jan 2012


I also "adopted" an orchid (a $1 special in a broken pot) and it has taken up a surprising amount of time trying to learn how to make it happy, plus time worrying that, even though it LOOKS happy, it will keel over any minute.

Only three months until pea-planting season!

beac

(9,992 posts)
15. "Peas on St. Patrick's Day" is a "rule" I've often heard and
Sat Feb 11, 2012, 10:47 AM
Feb 2012

I actually did it last year (well, 2 days earlier than St.at's really.) Worked out fine for me. I'm in Zone 6b. Do you know what zone you are in? http://planthardiness.ars.usda.gov/PHZMWeb/

beac

(9,992 posts)
18. I've never done potatoes, but I know many other DU gardeners have/do.
Mon Feb 13, 2012, 05:12 PM
Feb 2012

Try making a separate OP with your 'tater questions. I'm sure you'll get lots of helpful info.

Curmudgeoness

(18,219 posts)
3. I just love experiments! And people who are willing to do them.
Tue Jan 3, 2012, 08:31 PM
Jan 2012

I used to do this a lot, but got lazy, I suppose.

Thanks for doing the work....the results are impressive. (And I suppose this is why kids should not drink! Stunts growth! )

beac

(9,992 posts)
4. I go thru motivated and lazy stages with my experimenting...
Tue Jan 3, 2012, 09:22 PM
Jan 2012

The series of tubes definitely makes it easier to research things and decide what to try.

The hardest part of this project was getting a semi-clear/straight photo. Our 150+-year-old house has slanty floors (we rent) and the light coming in from the side window was making weird shadows. Also, my hands seem particularly talented at overcoming the "anti-shake" function. And I first copied the photos onto the laptop without Photoshop and had to start over on the one that does (once I found the cord for it.) LOL.

Denninmi

(6,581 posts)
5. Which kind of rubbing alcohol did you use?
Wed Jan 4, 2012, 06:27 AM
Jan 2012

Isopropyl or ethanol?

I'm guessing Isopropyl, because I can't imagine that denature ethanol rubbing alcohol would have yielded results much different from the gin.

beac

(9,992 posts)
6. Isopropyl
Wed Jan 4, 2012, 12:11 PM
Jan 2012

It was the only kind at the store.

Also, I wanted to make a full gallon of 11-to-1 mix and it's possible I erred too much on the side of caution when masuring out the amounts. Making a gallon in the way I did made the math more complicated-- I started with a store-bought gallon of spring water b/c I didn't have any empty gallon jugs and had to remove two cups to leave room for the RA and then calculate the ratio.

I also realized last night that the Cornell article says the liquor-to-water ratio should be one-to-seven, not one-to-eight (I got that in my head from a blog that linked to the CU paper), so all my gins were one-to-eight and it still worked fine. The CU paper does say that anywhere from a 4-6% solution works. Guess I proved that.

beac

(9,992 posts)
10. You're going to laugh, but it actually was Beefeaters!
Wed Jan 4, 2012, 06:26 PM
Jan 2012

Ordinarily, I wouldn't waste good hooch on flower bulbs, but I had an open bottle rattling around from a long-ago party and, since we aren't gin drinkers, it seemed frugal and greener to use it rather than go buy a fifth of the rot gut.

Please don't tell the martiniphiles...

 

naaman fletcher

(7,362 posts)
11. Perhaps I am being obtuse,
Wed Jan 4, 2012, 08:33 PM
Jan 2012

but why exactly are you wanting to kill flowers in the winter?

beac

(9,992 posts)
12. No, no, not kill.
Wed Jan 4, 2012, 08:47 PM
Jan 2012

The alcohol merely stunts their growth so they don't get super tall and fall over before they finish blooming. It doesn't harm the plant in any other way. In fact, my "gin blossoms" are healthier than the ones I grew in plain water.

Response to beac (Original post)

beac

(9,992 posts)
19. I think the odor of paperwhites must be like the flavor of cilantro--
Mon Feb 13, 2012, 05:17 PM
Feb 2012

some love it, some hate it. I am a lover of both.

We had paperwhites all over the house this winter. Granted, we have high ceilings (old house), so maybe that prevents the "cloying" some speak of.

I've heard that Zivas (the most common paperwhites you see on sale everywhere) are the smelliest and that other strains have milder scent.

beac

(9,992 posts)
20. This year, in addition to the usual "Ziva" paperwhites (the ones w/the offensive-to-some smell), I
Sun Nov 25, 2012, 05:52 PM
Nov 2012

am also trying some "Erlicheer", a variety that supposedly has a un-musky "honey-like" scent. They apparently require a longer period in the cold and dark and opinions vary on how well they do for forcing over pebbles, but I got them cheap and look forward to reporting back on them.



I'm also contemplating dipping my toe into hyacinth forcing. They really require a long, dark dormancy and I'm not sure there's space in my cold closet for them AND all the cheap Trader Joe's wine we have stuffed in there.

Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Gardening»Gin is better than rubbin...