Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

LuckyCharms

(22,645 posts)
Sat Mar 21, 2026, 09:22 PM Mar 21

I was talking to a good friend of mine who just got a speeding ticket.

They're a good driver who never got a speeding ticket before, and I never got one either, so I don't know the answer to this question.

I didn't ask how fast they were going, but it sounds like it wasn't horribly over the limit.

Can a judge reduce the fine if you go to court?

Based upon a good driving record?

I'll read all responses...thank you in advance.

Edit: they were doing 57 in a 40, the ticket was written for 51 in a 40mph. Also, any idea about license points and insurance dings for something like this?

23 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
I was talking to a good friend of mine who just got a speeding ticket. (Original Post) LuckyCharms Mar 21 OP
I got one dropped because I dressed nice. multigraincracker Mar 21 #1
This is what I'm looking for. Thank you, mgc. n/t LuckyCharms Mar 21 #2
What a nice judge Niagara Mar 21 #5
Tossed it out. No fine and not on my record. multigraincracker Mar 21 #10
That's great news Niagara Mar 21 #11
I think the judge liked my respect for multigraincracker Mar 21 #12
Depends on the judge and the legal fine definition in the jurisdiction. You can try cbabe Mar 21 #3
Thank you, cbabe. LuckyCharms Mar 21 #6
Almost always worth contesting it points Mar 21 #4
Thanks, points. n/t LuckyCharms Mar 21 #8
It's been a long time since my last traffic violation, but in my state you could plead circumstances Ilikepurple Mar 21 #17
Yes, that was my exact experience. In fact, the officer who wrote the ticket insisted I go to court, because Sogo Mar 21 #7
Gotcha. Thank you. LuckyCharms Mar 21 #9
About the points. Lochloosa Mar 21 #13
Dings on the driving record would depend on the insurance carrier. Worth trying to keep it off your record to avoid a cbabe Mar 21 #14
Absolutely. Rizen Mar 21 #15
My wife was once stopped for speeding. Squaredeal Mar 21 #16
17 mph over the speed limit isn't barely over MichMan Mar 21 #18
some states let u take a driving safety course. mopinko Mar 21 #19
Sorry to hear True Dough Mar 21 #20
Thank you, True Dough. LuckyCharms Mar 22 #23
I've been a bad boy driving, at least before I got cruise control in a hybrid car. NNadir Mar 22 #21
That friend of yours... LuckyCharms Mar 22 #22

multigraincracker

(37,651 posts)
1. I got one dropped because I dressed nice.
Sat Mar 21, 2026, 09:28 PM
Mar 21

Showed respect for the court. Judge asked about my perfect record and let me off.
It can happen.

multigraincracker

(37,651 posts)
12. I think the judge liked my respect for
Sat Mar 21, 2026, 09:39 PM
Mar 21

Him and the court. Plus my only ticket and it was for 10 over.

cbabe

(6,643 posts)
3. Depends on the judge and the legal fine definition in the jurisdiction. You can try
Sat Mar 21, 2026, 09:30 PM
Mar 21

pleading your case. The judge may be required to follow fine guidelines. Or a toss up if they’re a hard case or tending to lenient.

points

(48 posts)
4. Almost always worth contesting it
Sat Mar 21, 2026, 09:31 PM
Mar 21

In some states, if you contest it the officer needs to appear, and that rarely happens.
Also just for making the effort of contesting, it's pretty often the case that you'll get a reduced fine or have it dismissed.
Of course YMMV and the "is it worth it?" question depends on how much an afternoon showing up to do this in person is worth to you compared with the ticket's cost.

Ilikepurple

(672 posts)
17. It's been a long time since my last traffic violation, but in my state you could plead circumstances
Sat Mar 21, 2026, 10:18 PM
Mar 21

Rather than contesting the violation itself. Almost every young driver I knew knew they could get their ticket cost reduced somewhat automatically the first time. Which traffic violations are reported to insurance companies varies by state. Perhaps if you named the stat, somebody with particularized knowledge can help the determination. Here, if you looked on the back of the ticket it gave you three options. Agree and pay, contest in court, and plead circumstances in court. The latter is what I’d generally look to do on first ticket where I admit the infraction. One might get lucky and get the infraction reduced or the accusation of violation withdrawn, which would be great in these days of more aggressive insurance “point” systems.

Sogo

(7,191 posts)
7. Yes, that was my exact experience. In fact, the officer who wrote the ticket insisted I go to court, because
Sat Mar 21, 2026, 09:32 PM
Mar 21

I had never had a speeding ticket before. The judge acknowledged that but still fined me, but at a substantially reduced rate (I can't remember now how much since it was so long ago.) Additionally, if I went to a one-day driving class (which I did), it kept the ticket off my record. This was in California in the 80's.

Lochloosa

(16,733 posts)
13. About the points.
Sat Mar 21, 2026, 09:59 PM
Mar 21

In Florida, you can take a short online course and the points go away. That is what will affect the insurance

If they do raise the rates, get quotes from other companies. Usually the other companies will lure you in with a good price then raise the rates after that. You should always get three quotes every year for auto insurance. Forget "brand" loyalty, that flew out the window years ago.

cbabe

(6,643 posts)
14. Dings on the driving record would depend on the insurance carrier. Worth trying to keep it off your record to avoid a
Sat Mar 21, 2026, 09:59 PM
Mar 21

rate increase. Moving violations can be costly.

Rizen

(1,079 posts)
15. Absolutely.
Sat Mar 21, 2026, 10:01 PM
Mar 21

My cousin, who was caught speeding, went to traffic court and they reduced his fine and the charge even though he was totally guilty.

Squaredeal

(733 posts)
16. My wife was once stopped for speeding.
Sat Mar 21, 2026, 10:17 PM
Mar 21

“Do you know how fast you were going?”, the police officer asked her. “ How would I know, with two screaming kids in the back?”, she answered. He gave her a ticket for not wearing a safety belt, although she was. It was a much lower fine and no points.

MichMan

(17,149 posts)
18. 17 mph over the speed limit isn't barely over
Sat Mar 21, 2026, 10:30 PM
Mar 21

The officer is going to likely not going to be very happy about being there given they already reduced it by 6 mph

mopinko

(73,723 posts)
19. some states let u take a driving safety course.
Sat Mar 21, 2026, 10:52 PM
Mar 21

maybe he can find out if your state offers diversion.
it’s always worth going, cuz cops rarely bother to show up in court.
(i’ve done both.)

1 ticket shouldnt affect insurance. esp a small 1 like this. i have had a few fender benders in my day, and a couple piddly tickets. but havent had trouble w insurance. i’m never gonna b drunk driving 100 mph in the wrong lane.

NNadir

(38,039 posts)
21. I've been a bad boy driving, at least before I got cruise control in a hybrid car.
Sun Mar 22, 2026, 01:43 AM
Mar 22

The situation depends on a number of factors, among them, where and when the offense occurred, the court, and the availability of the ticketing officer.

It varies from State to State. The worst ticket I ever got was for missing the "No left turn" sign. I had insurance, but didn't put the new insurance card in the car. The cop in question was a real bastard, he had a huge collection of offenders waiting for him that day in court. He obviously loved writing tickets and was very rude about it. The judge claimed he had no discretion, and fined me $800, even though I brought proof that I had been insured at the time but simply didn't have the card in my glove compartment.

The outcome generally depends, again, on the state, the court, the locality and the law.

I have had tickets dismissed because the cop didn't show up, and in one case, because the cop did show up, but recommended the case be dismissed because he had something to do. He was actually a nice guy. It involved a fender bender, and he gave both parties a ticket, and he dismissed both tickets. This made the other party happy as well as me, and we both apologized for our roles to one another for our respective roles in the whole thing.

When my wife was young and driving with me, I would sometimes get pulled over for bullshit reasons but not ticketed but "warned." I sometimes thought it was about them wanting to check my wife out, because as a young woman she seemed to inspire a lot of unwanted male attention. (I'm not quite sure she wanted my attention, but she seems to have relented.) I almost never got pulled over like that when driving alone, but when she was in the car, it happened several times.

I haven't had a ticket in many years, probably because I bought my car because of its excellent fuel economy, which is at its best when running on cruise control. I set it to do the speed limit, which annoys a lot of people who don't want to do the speed limit, who tailgate and even go to the extreme lengths to do dangerous passes illegally. I slow down and let them by. A few times I've come upon these people getting tickets when I drove down the road, which I confess leads to some smirking on my part.

My car has that automatic adaptive cruise control that prevents me from tailgating and which stops or slows the car when obstructions or slowing cars in front. This is good because I'm an old fart.

A person who claims to be a friend of mine, suggested that the best way for me to deal with an eye problem I was having was to drive to the ophthalmologist with both eyes closed to allow my brain to adjust. I wasn't quite sure it was good medical advice, but perhaps the adaptive cruise control would have prevented a bad outcome. However, because I found the idea to be somewhat dubious, I drove with my eyes open.

Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»I was talking to a good f...