Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

mysteryowl

(8,143 posts)
Tue Jan 13, 2026, 07:36 PM 14 hrs ago

What is your favorite birthday cake?

I have a friend with a birthday and I want to make a cake from scratch.

Thanks!

34 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
What is your favorite birthday cake? (Original Post) mysteryowl 14 hrs ago OP
generally something involving chocolate and raspberries ... surrealAmerican 14 hrs ago #1
Yes, that is one approach. Thanks mysteryowl 14 hrs ago #3
Vanilla cake with vanilla icing topped with coconut shreds bucolic_frolic 14 hrs ago #2
Don't make something that looks or tastes like "birthday cake." Intractable 14 hrs ago #4
Maybe a fun shape? mysteryowl 13 hrs ago #6
Something not white! Intractable 13 hrs ago #8
Like a strawberry cake? mysteryowl 13 hrs ago #12
Devil's food with buttercream icing some_of_us_are_sane 14 hrs ago #5
Yum mysteryowl 13 hrs ago #7
Pumpkin and Licorice Ice Cream cake with dark chocolate and caramel. with a cherry on top, of course. Wonder Why 13 hrs ago #9
Wow, that is elaborate. mysteryowl 13 hrs ago #10
It's elaborate when you add the pecans, Reese's Pieces, marshmallows, Jelly Bellies and other goodies. Wonder Why 13 hrs ago #15
OH WOW! mysteryowl 13 hrs ago #17
Who doesn't love a Carrot Cake.... Lochloosa 13 hrs ago #11
My all time BEST birthday cake! hedda_foil 13 hrs ago #13
Fantastic! mysteryowl 13 hrs ago #18
I'm a the darker-the-chocolate the better cake lover, but this sounds quite fun, except how.... electric_blue68 13 hrs ago #20
It's sublime -- especially with the lemon. hedda_foil 9 hrs ago #32
Interesting! Not sure I've ever had French... electric_blue68 7 hrs ago #33
My aunt made a great zucchini chocolate cake. My mom applegrove 13 hrs ago #14
Red velvet mercuryblues 13 hrs ago #16
You can't go wrong with chocolate cake and chocolate frosting ... Diamond_Dog 13 hrs ago #19
I like a chocolate and raspberry torte. debm55 12 hrs ago #21
Cherry Nut Cake. My mom made one for me every birthday as I was growing up. Fla Dem 12 hrs ago #22
Yum mysteryowl 12 hrs ago #24
My sis for a bunch of years made "ugly" cakes that were fun... electric_blue68 12 hrs ago #23
That is really fun! Thanks mysteryowl 12 hrs ago #25
YW! 👍 electric_blue68 12 hrs ago #26
chocolate cheesecake with cherry or raspberry topping HappyH 12 hrs ago #27
Yum mysteryowl 11 hrs ago #28
That would be the one on my 21st birthday... Enter stage left 11 hrs ago #29
yellow cake with orange frosting Eugene 10 hrs ago #30
Ice Cream Cake Roll Zackzzzz 10 hrs ago #31
My favorite is Boston Cream Pie Tree Lady 7 hrs ago #34

surrealAmerican

(11,744 posts)
1. generally something involving chocolate and raspberries ...
Tue Jan 13, 2026, 07:39 PM
14 hrs ago

... but that's just me. What does your friend like?

bucolic_frolic

(54,111 posts)
2. Vanilla cake with vanilla icing topped with coconut shreds
Tue Jan 13, 2026, 07:44 PM
14 hrs ago

Say what you want, it is vanilla and it is sweet!

Intractable

(1,682 posts)
4. Don't make something that looks or tastes like "birthday cake."
Tue Jan 13, 2026, 07:47 PM
14 hrs ago

Bake a real cake with actual flavors!

They can taste the "love" if you make that an ingredient. Sounds like you will.

mysteryowl

(8,143 posts)
6. Maybe a fun shape?
Tue Jan 13, 2026, 07:49 PM
13 hrs ago

Maybe a carrot cake with cream cheese frosting in the shape of a carrot.

mysteryowl

(8,143 posts)
7. Yum
Tue Jan 13, 2026, 07:51 PM
13 hrs ago

"Devil's food cake" is used both to describe a moist, dark, cake with an intense chocolate flavour.

Wonder Why

(6,563 posts)
9. Pumpkin and Licorice Ice Cream cake with dark chocolate and caramel. with a cherry on top, of course.
Tue Jan 13, 2026, 07:53 PM
13 hrs ago

Wonder Why

(6,563 posts)
15. It's elaborate when you add the pecans, Reese's Pieces, marshmallows, Jelly Bellies and other goodies.
Tue Jan 13, 2026, 08:16 PM
13 hrs ago

But I like my cake too plain for that.

hedda_foil

(16,912 posts)
13. My all time BEST birthday cake!
Tue Jan 13, 2026, 08:07 PM
13 hrs ago

3 layers of lemon cake filled with lemon curd and raspberry French buttercream, with white icing and lots of frosting flowers! Yum!

electric_blue68

(26,015 posts)
20. I'm a the darker-the-chocolate the better cake lover, but this sounds quite fun, except how....
Tue Jan 13, 2026, 08:41 PM
13 hrs ago

does the raspberry and French buttercream "mesh" togther taste wise?

electric_blue68

(26,015 posts)
33. Interesting! Not sure I've ever had French...
Wed Jan 14, 2026, 01:52 AM
7 hrs ago

buttercream. I do like raspberries, and lemon.

applegrove

(130,421 posts)
14. My aunt made a great zucchini chocolate cake. My mom
Tue Jan 13, 2026, 08:07 PM
13 hrs ago

made a chocolate cake with oatmeal in it for all our birthdays. Both were delicious. I don't have either recipe but you can probably find them online with ratings for how much they were liked. The Oatmeal Chocolate cake was from Nova Scotia. It was my mom's Aunt Frances'.

electric_blue68

(26,015 posts)
23. My sis for a bunch of years made "ugly" cakes that were fun...
Tue Jan 13, 2026, 08:53 PM
12 hrs ago

Basically a white cake usually 2 or 3 layers but each with a different colored food dye, and the icing would be yet another color! 😄

So let's say - cake layers - orange, yellow, blue and purple frosting!

Haven't thought of those in decades.
What would it more fun/funny if cooking times compatible one lemon cake layer but colored blue!

Anyway, chocolate, carrot, cocconut, or lemon would be my favorites (with chocolate way ahead of the others). Although chocolate coconut combo sounds yummy; I love the Mounds candy bar.

Have fun what you bake! 🎂 👍

HappyH

(183 posts)
27. chocolate cheesecake with cherry or raspberry topping
Tue Jan 13, 2026, 09:36 PM
12 hrs ago

Not very difficult to make. My wife bakes one for me every year.

Enter stage left

(4,281 posts)
29. That would be the one on my 21st birthday...
Tue Jan 13, 2026, 10:34 PM
11 hrs ago

Damned if I remember what it was, but it was my favorite!

Eugene

(66,830 posts)
30. yellow cake with orange frosting
Tue Jan 13, 2026, 10:55 PM
10 hrs ago

or chocolate cake with chocolate frosting (easier to get)

Tree Lady

(13,023 posts)
34. My favorite is Boston Cream Pie
Wed Jan 14, 2026, 02:22 AM
7 hrs ago

Basically yellow cake, cut in half with custard inside and dark chocolate frosting a bit thinner than regular frosting on top.

You can make all of it by scratch.

Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»What is your favorite bir...