Four House Republicans force vote on ACA subsidies, bucking GOP leadership
Source: CNBC
Published Wed, Dec 17 2025 9:44 AM EST Updated 8 Min Ago
Four moderate House Republicans rebelled against House Speaker Mike Johnson on Wednesday, joining Democrats to force a vote on extending key Affordable Care Act subsidies that are set to expire at the end of the year. If approved, the measure will extend ACA tax credits for three years.
If those subsidies expire as scheduled, the prices of Obamacare health insurance premiums that millions of Americans personally pay will skyrocket. The stunning defections by the quarter of Republicans came a day after Johnson, R-La., said that GOP leaders would not allow a vote under normal procedures on keeping the enhanced ACA tax credits alive into 2026. Johnson earlier Wednesday morning urged GOP caucus members not to join Democrats in the procedural end-run around him.
In the face of a lack of significant efforts by congressional Republicans to extend the credits, House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries, D-N.Y., in November created a so-called discharge petition, which would force a vote on such an extension once it obtained signatures from 218 House members. Democrats only have 214 members, so they needed four Republicans for that measure to work.
Johnson on Wednesday was asked about the discharge petition on CNBCs Squawk Box. He said that doing an end-run around the majority party, the speaker or the regular process is not the best way to make law. But about two hours later, four moderate Republicans signed the petition: Brian Fitzpatrick, Rob Bresnahan and Ryan Mackenzie, all of Pennsylvania; and Mike Lawler of New York signed the petition.
Read more: https://www.cnbc.com/2025/12/17/johnson-aca-republicans-health.html
Article updated.
Original article -
Four moderate House Republicans rebelled against House Speaker Mike Johnson on Wednesday to force a vote on extending key ACA subsidies set to expire at the end of the year.
Johnson earlier Wednesday urged his fellow Republicans not to join Democrats in a last-ditch effort to extend key Affordable Care Act tax credits that are due to expire at the end of the year. Johnson told CNBCs Squawk Box that doing an end-run around the majority party, the Speaker or the regular process is not the best way to make law.
The comment came a day after the speaker blocked moderate Republicans from getting a vote on extending the life of enhanced ACA subsidies, which are set to expire at the end of December. Obamacare health insurance premiums for millions of Americans will sharply rise if the tax credits expire.
Johnson and GOP leadership are pushing a separate healthcare bill that would not extend the enhanced subsidies. The House will vote on that bill, which would provide cost-sharing aid for consumers, on Wednesday.
rampartd
(3,578 posts)who are the four?
mtg, seems likely.
underpants
(194,588 posts)rampartd
(3,578 posts)BumRushDaShow
(165,170 posts)They are just NBC's now-spun off cable business channel. They have clown characters like Jim Cramer on there but they are always quick - usually just ahead of AP - with breaking stories (including non-business related, and even beating out their original parent network of NBC).
underpants
(194,588 posts)Reps. Brian Fitzpatrick of Pennsylvania, Mike Lawler of New York, Rob Bresnahan of Pennsylvania and Ryan Mackenzie of Pennsylvania signed the discharge petition filed by House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries hours after House GOP leaders rejected attempts by Fitzpatrick and other Republican moderates to seek a floor vote on extending the subsidies used by more than 20 million Americans.
Ray Bruns
(5,930 posts)doing an end-run around the majority party, the Speaker or the regular process is not the best way to make law.
highplainsdem
(59,635 posts)Under House rules, seven legislative days need to lapse before a bill, discharged by such a petition, comes to the floor. The House, however, is only scheduled to be in session until Friday, before lawmakers head home for a two-week holiday recess.
The House is set to return to Washington on Jan. 6, meaning the vote on the three-year extension will likely be held in the second week of that month unless Johnson attempts to expedite it to the floor.
And if it does pass the House, it still faces hurdles in the Senate, where Republicans rejected the three-year funding extension on the floor just last week. Majority Leader John Thune, R-S.D., has slammed the Covid-era ACA subsidies and said he favors a broader overhaul, not just an extension of those funds.
patphil
(8,670 posts)Once more Johnson fails to keep his people in line. He's not gonna last through January.
SergeStorms
(19,905 posts)anyone hoping for an extension of the ACA before year's end is SOL. Business as usual for the House GOP. No business at all.
InstantGratification
(413 posts)We still have the Senate to clear and then TSF's signature. Hopefully, when the full House votes on this, swing state R's will decide if it is going to pass anyway, they may as well vote for it to show their voters that they were independent enough to buck party leadership and the bill passes by a large margin. That may pressure the Senate to do the same. Kind of like how the Epstein files vote played out, once the discharge petition was passed, nobody wanted to be on the wrong side of public opinion and it passed with landslide votes in both chambers.
Jacson6
(1,737 posts)JT45242
(3,813 posts)No hiding behind -- Mikey never put it to a vote....
They will either have to go with Mango Mussolini and Mikey boy against the wishes of the majority of their constituents who want the ACA and stand by that vote in the general election
OR
Do the right thing and put the pressure on the Senate
Even many districts that were gerrymandered to be "safely republican" may fall under the weight of so many unpopular policies, high inflation, a recession, and a war to steal oil and minerals in Venzuela
spooky3
(38,223 posts)Call and email their representatives daily.
BigmanPigman
(54,533 posts)I have called every single GOP senator several times since 2016. I have a method which allows me to be seen as a tRump supporter and constituent when I call their offices. I live in a "blue" state so I call the GOP ones. It takes about 5 minutes and it is worth it. I got the idea from a fellow protester in 2017. I use Zillow to give the staffers an address, zip code etc so they think I am a legit GOP voter.
wolfie001
(6,957 posts)Because the rePUKES are psychopaths.
Pluvious
(5,192 posts)Then I checked the current article copy, and I see they corrected it to say:
"The stunning defections by the quartet of Republicans came a..."
It's nice to know that I'm not the only one victimized by AutoCorrect
EnergizedLib
(2,914 posts)Brian Fitzpatrick? Huh? I guess thats a spinoff from the Fitzmagic Ryan delivered in the NFL.
Warpy
(114,363 posts)Premiums will go up since there is no way they'll be able to reinstate the subsidies before the end of the month. It's too little and WAY too late and they know it "but we did the right thing, you poor dimwit constituents."
Color me unimpressed.
maxsolomon
(38,108 posts)um... the QUARTET of Republicans.
A quarter of House Repukes is 220/4 = 55.
BaronChocula
(3,967 posts)Their inaction, incompetence, and malfeasance is baked in among those who will vote in the midterms. Dracula is drooling.
Wiz Imp
(8,746 posts)to vote in favor of this. Since it got the signatures in the House, it is almost certain to pass the House. The Senate already voted against it, but if there is overwhelming public support , they could change their minds (like happened with the Epstein files). It's unlikely, but Republicans are getting more and more scared of the consequences from the voters so you never know.
Collins, Hawley, Murkowski & Sullivan voted for it when the vote came up last week (Daines didn't vote, the remaining 48 Republicans voted no). That means 9 more Republican votes are needed to overcome the filibuster.