New Orleans attack would've had 'completely different outcome' if steel barriers were used, inventor says
Source: The Guardian
Sat 11 Jan 2025 07.00 EST
The deadly New Years Day truck attack in New Orleans would have had a completely different outcome if city officials had put out 700lb (317kg) barriers that they bought years earlier and have a track record of preventing intentional vehicle rammings, the blockades inventor has told the Guardian.
But the city did not have a full slate of accessories to help move and deploy those steel Archer barriers quickly in the way they were designed to be and how authorities elsewhere have managed to do it, Peter Whitford, the chief executive officer of the Meridian Rapid Defense Group, said in an interview. Though the Archers had stopped a relatively similar ramming attack in California exactly a year earlier, in New Orleans, officials came to regard them as too cumbersome to put out and pick back up, according to prior reporting from the Guardian.
New Orleans emergency preparedness officials therefore stored them away. And they were one of three types of barriers meant to stop motorists from purposely targeting crowds that were missing in action on 1 January when an Islamic State (IS) terror group sympathizer fatally struck 14 people while injuring about 35 others on the citys famous Bourbon Street.
Whitford late Thursday said the attack and subsequent revelations about why New Orleans chose not to set up its Archers had prompted him and other members of his defense company to travel to the city and personally handle furnishing its public safety establishment with the deployment equipment it evidently lacked.
Read more: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/jan/11/archer-barriers-new-orleans-truck-attack
IronLionZion
(47,283 posts)or an American from Texas to do it.
LauraInLA
(1,437 posts)I believe they had some kind of barriers which had been taken down for repair or something. I honestly feel like cities should have been conscious of this.
IronLionZion
(47,283 posts)lots of big pickup trucks in America. It can happen anywhere.
I'm uneasy in big crowds for other reasons. But the risk of a truck ramming into a crowd is yet another thing to worry about.
Igel
(36,350 posts)One is ICE.
The other is EV.
The EV version weighs something like 30% more than the ICE version.
The rental chosen by the killer, who may have been a fanatic but wasn't entirely stupid, was the ICE version.
The more mass at a given speed, the harder it is to stop. I mean, high school physics kids have learned this since I was in HS physics in '75. If I wanted to smash crap with a vehicle, I'd go for heavy.
As a bonus, if you damage the battery just right you can get it to catch on fire--and battery fires are hard to extinguish because those Li+ cells want to release their energy. So there's always that. I wonder if his Air BnB had a charging station or if he'd charged it recently.
IronLionZion
(47,283 posts)Where did you see that it wasn't the EV version?
Srkdqltr
(7,825 posts)They could have had trash trucks or other large trucks to block the ends of the street and the sidewalk. If they had known.
LauraInLA
(1,437 posts)Srkdqltr
(7,825 posts)Roy Rolling
(7,227 posts)The new governor took office Jan 2024 and sent state police into New Orleans to fight crime.
After tons of PR about how crime had been eliminated they forgot to do their job.
He took the authority to send police, he didnt take responsibility for success, just TV coverage for sending them.
His first mission in 2024 was to send National Guard troops to babysit Gov Abbott of Texas at the Mexico border800 miles away from Louisiana.
New Orleans couldve used those troops and expertise. Theres danger in Louisiana. The most dangerous place is between Gov. Jeff Landry and a TV camera.
Igel
(36,350 posts)This wasn't a decision by the NOPD. It was done by the NOHSEP.
Unless you want the governor to take full control over all preparations for everything in NOLA because you think the mayor and civilian city government there are so incompetent that a (R) governor can do better and must do more than send in some state troopers to help patrol.
Personally, I think the police probably did okay. (Although some are criticizing them because they shot the killer when video shows they didn't need to; a police review cleared them and properly so, I think. The only drawback is that they can't interrogate him and find out if he had contacts in Egypt or Montreal, where he'd visited in the previous year.)
rickford66
(5,725 posts)Any where a pedestrian could be hit by a vehicle, hence practically everywhere.
yardwork
(64,926 posts)Bourbon Street, a few other places where tourists gather.
But yes, it's easy to Monday morning quarterback and say coulda shoulda woulda. People intent on creating chaos find ways.
forgotmylogin
(7,701 posts)In my brain, I'm wondering if several rows of of regular cinderblocks laid out on a road strategically in a grid would serve to stop or slow a speeding vehicle. They're not huge, but seems they would act like caltrops and cause axle and tire damage if someone tried to speed through them.
hueymahl
(2,678 posts)The NOLA leadership should be fired for their utter incompetence. The deaths are on their heads.