Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

BumRushDaShow

(145,061 posts)
Sat Jan 11, 2025, 07:31 AM Yesterday

Reservoir in Pacific Palisades was out of commission when fire started

Source: NBC News

Jan. 10, 2025, 4:57 PM EST / Updated Jan. 10, 2025, 7:46 PM EST


A 117-million gallon reservoir in one of the Los Angeles communities ravaged by wildfires was out of commission when the fire started in the area on Tuesday.

The Santa Ynez Reservoir in the Pacific Palisades has been closed for repairs after a covering designed to preserve water quality tore. The Los Angeles Times first reported that the reservoir was offline.

The reservoir’s status may have limited the water system’s ability to provide consistent pressure for firefighters, but Marty Adams, a former general manager of the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power, said it is unlikely to have made a significant difference in the battle against the Palisades Fire, which burned through 20,000 acres as of Friday afternoon.

“It was out of service. I don’t know exactly how long it’s been out of service,” Adams said. During firefighters’ response to the Palisades Fire, some high elevation fire hydrants dried up, hampering efforts to fight the blaze.

Read more: https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/reservoir-pacific-palisades-was-commission-fire-started-rcna187217

23 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Reservoir in Pacific Palisades was out of commission when fire started (Original Post) BumRushDaShow Yesterday OP
How did Trump know? live love laugh Yesterday #1
I kind of feel sorry for urban planners, or the people tasked Mike 03 Yesterday #2
So they should have postponed the repairs indefinitely fargone Yesterday #10
and the barriers were down on bourbon st due to repairs rampartd Yesterday #3
The barriers in NO are only effective for 10mph or less Cattledog Yesterday #4
Governments, national and local Miguelito Loveless 1 hr ago #23
On top of everything else, city government has to be clairvoyant? Marthe48 Yesterday #5
Only if they are Democrats. travelingthrulife Yesterday #7
I guess nobody was expecting January wildfires IronLionZion Yesterday #6
I think it's been drained for quite awhile. It's empty on Google Maps. Our satellite in google maps LeftInTX Yesterday #9
The limiting factor was the pipe DENVERPOPS Yesterday #11
Then idiot hobby drone operators crash into firefighting aircraft IronLionZion 20 hrs ago #18
The winds were up to 100 mph. BidenRocks 19 hrs ago #19
Canadian 'Super Scooper' plane grounded after hitting civilian drone over Los Angeles wildfires IronLionZion 18 hrs ago #20
That plane that was hit DENVERPOPS 18 hrs ago #21
This! Chemical Bill 14 hrs ago #22
Why is this story here? It is counter-productive. Tertullian Yesterday #8
It absolutely needs to be posted Polybius Yesterday #12
??? BumRushDaShow Yesterday #15
Someone's getting fired n/t Polybius Yesterday #13
Newsom can forget about presidential run question everything Yesterday #14
Completely disagree n/t Pachamama 23 hrs ago #16
Things happen... Bettie 22 hrs ago #17

Mike 03

(17,615 posts)
2. I kind of feel sorry for urban planners, or the people tasked
Sat Jan 11, 2025, 07:50 AM
Yesterday

with deciding what get does when. It probably seemed rational at the time to do repairs on the reservoir in January rather than, say, July or August. But as the article says, it may not have made any difference--I understand this.

It is going to be challenging to adapt to a reality in which calamities can happen any hour of any day of the year. Even the hurricanes began early this year. We had two years of flash flooding during monsoon, followed by a year of practically no rain. This is the first winter I can remember in years where we have not had a snowflake fall by mid January.

fargone

(254 posts)
10. So they should have postponed the repairs indefinitely
Sat Jan 11, 2025, 12:16 PM
Yesterday

And let the water quality deteriorate. Or scheduled it for the winter when most of the rain occurs rather than late summer when most of the CA fires occur. Oh, wait...

Cattledog

(6,428 posts)
4. The barriers in NO are only effective for 10mph or less
Sat Jan 11, 2025, 08:05 AM
Yesterday

Basically useless. Wouldn't have stopped that guy. The Article above states that the reservoir was down for repairs.

Miguelito Loveless

(4,736 posts)
23. Governments, national and local
Sun Jan 12, 2025, 03:32 PM
1 hr ago

Keep “deferring” maintenance to save money.

The results are predictable.

IronLionZion

(47,283 posts)
6. I guess nobody was expecting January wildfires
Sat Jan 11, 2025, 09:39 AM
Yesterday
Such a move would have reduced demand and helped to increase water pressure elsewhere.

Still, he said, water likely couldn’t flow fast enough to meet firefighters’ incredible demands.

“The limiting factor was the pipe,” Adams said, adding that water infrastructure is designed to allow firefighters to extinguish a few houses or a commercial building, not a wildfire.

“Systems are designed for a typical city-based fire, not an entire city catching on fire,” he said. ”There’s no domestic water system that’s built to this scale.”

LeftInTX

(31,161 posts)
9. I think it's been drained for quite awhile. It's empty on Google Maps. Our satellite in google maps
Sat Jan 11, 2025, 11:40 AM
Yesterday

is older than our streetview. This streetview is from June 2024, but the overhead was obviously earlier because the overhead does not show the new construction.

Reservoir



Cleared land in satellite view (Obviously before June 2024)

Same spot June 2024


Based on other landmarks in the satellite pics, it was taken either April 2024 or October 2023.

Anyway satellite is only updated every year or so.

DENVERPOPS

(10,301 posts)
11. The limiting factor was the pipe
Sat Jan 11, 2025, 01:37 PM
Yesterday

That is it in a nutshell...............No matter the amount of water available, No matter what pressure you use, there is a limit of volume of water that you can push thru a pipe of different diameters..........The city mains are not designed, like Iron Lion says to handle a hundred hydrants, fifty hydrants or even ten hydrants.......

Also, pressure at a lower elevation is more than pressure at a higher elevation. The pressure drops a pound for every two feet of elevation. In addition, if all the water is being used at a lower elevation, obviously none will reach the higher pipes.

It boggles my mind, all the mis-information being broadcast by the media, including what is being spewed by Trump. Including by members of the Command of the LAFD.........

In my opinion, the only way to effectively and safely fight a "conflagration" such as this, is by Air........

Another point that no one has mentioned is that each structure has water supplied out of the same water mains as the hydrants.
During the fire and collapse faucets and toilets are broken and just running water continuously......take a single structure's water loss from this situation and multiply it by hundreds, if not thousands of structures........................

IronLionZion

(47,283 posts)
18. Then idiot hobby drone operators crash into firefighting aircraft
Sat Jan 11, 2025, 08:31 PM
20 hrs ago

exacerbating the situation.

I agree that air is the best way for this widespread level of wildfires. There needs to be more firefighting aircraft involved. our country should probably invest in some and send them wherever they are needed. California is getting help from Canada but we should have them here in America too.

IronLionZion

(47,283 posts)
20. Canadian 'Super Scooper' plane grounded after hitting civilian drone over Los Angeles wildfires
Sat Jan 11, 2025, 10:13 PM
18 hrs ago
https://www.cnn.com/2025/01/10/us/super-scooper-drone-collision-la-fire-canada-hnk-intl/index.html

There have been firefighting aircraft working in the area. The grounding because of high winds was temporary, like Tuesday night into Wednesday morning. Then flying resumed.

DENVERPOPS

(10,301 posts)
21. That plane that was hit
Sat Jan 11, 2025, 10:41 PM
18 hrs ago

was one of 19 that Canada sent us to help out..........

For decades, it has been recommended that we have a fleet of aircraft of all sizes, converted to tankers for fighting wildland fires.

The small planes and helicopters drop 500 gallons, maybe 1,000. The DC-10's drop 10,000 gallons...........

The local governments, state governments, and Federal governments can certainly have them standing by, year round, and staffed year round, not just in the summer months......

It is January! And we here in Colorado have been having RED FLAG warnings this past month. The number of Wildfires across the nation have grown immensely, and are certain to grow to even much higher numbers in the months/years ahead.

Tertullian

(70 posts)
8. Why is this story here? It is counter-productive.
Sat Jan 11, 2025, 11:20 AM
Yesterday

At this moment of severe suffering at the hands of climate change and those who refuse to take emergency government action to combat climate change, why post an article like this?

We don't know all of the facts. We don't know whether the facts alleged in the article are true. We don't know, even if they are true, whether this made any difference at all.

There's no need to post articles here on DU that might tend to bring California's excellent government officials into some kind of fake controversy.

Anyway, that's my 2 cents.

BumRushDaShow

(145,061 posts)
15. ???
Sat Jan 11, 2025, 02:33 PM
Yesterday

There are a number of things going on with the area's infrastructure outside of climate change.

One of the articles I read earlier in the week was that in some areas, the power was cut in an attempt to avoid wire sparking that could trigger more fires (something that had happened in previous CA fires). However doing that may have also impacted the water pumps to some of the hydrants (and apparently those pumps had no backup power or the backups failed).

All of this is part of assessing fixable weaknesses and "Lessons Learned" in order to plug gaps and improve future outcomes.

None of this has anything to do with the current state/county/municipal government response but would be useful for them for planning purposes.

The one thing I noticed that is rarely mentioned is that the same thing happened in Maui.

Bettie

(17,471 posts)
17. Things happen...
Sat Jan 11, 2025, 06:39 PM
22 hrs ago

there is almost always something under repair in most cities.

It happens. It isn't some nefarious plot. I doubt that someone in the city or state government said "let's fix this reservoir right now because i think there's going to be a fire!"

Shit. Happens.

Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Reservoir in Pacific Pali...