Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

BumRushDaShow

(144,280 posts)
Fri Nov 22, 2024, 05:25 PM Nov 22

Advocates fear national book ban under unified GOP government

Source: The Hill

11/22/24 6:00 AM ET


A Republican trifecta in Washington is raising concerns over the potential for national book ban legislation. Congressional Republicans have shown increased interest in the possibility, with House members recently hosting a hearing on the topic and Project 2025 laying out how a national ban could work. Advocates highlight that book bans have been popular in states with total GOP control, and they are preparing for a potential federal push before the second Trump presidency begins.

“Certainly, we think it’s a concern. You know, part of what we’ve watched over the last three years is the way in which different states” with unified GOP control “have passed sensorial legislation that has led book banning,” said Kasey Meehan, director of the Freedom to Read program at PEN America. “I think it’s something for us … to continue to be vigilant on and to be, you know, watching the extent to which state legislation that has led to book bans starts appearing as a potential federal policy,” Meehan added.

Book bans are of course nothing new, but legislation relating to school reading lists and the contents of library shelves have exploded since students returned to class amid the COVID-19 pandemic. “Over the past two years, there have been over 200 bills in state legislatures proposing — and some that have passed — that would institute statewide book bans in school libraries and/or criminalized librarians for providing access to books that some people object to. So, to see that activity happen at that scale, if this would move to the federal level, I think it’s definitely a concern to Americans across the country,” said Cindy Hohl, president of the American Library Association (ALA).

The currently Democratic-majority Senate Judiciary Committee held a hearing on the issue last year called “Book Bans: Examining How Censorship Limits Liberty and Literature.” While Republicans generally avoid using the word “ban” on the issue, many took the opportunity to demonstrate their support for keeping some books out of the classroom.

Read more: https://thehill.com/homenews/education/5003292-national-book-ban-gop-government-censorship/

10 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Advocates fear national book ban under unified GOP government (Original Post) BumRushDaShow Nov 22 OP
Concerned about self-censorship by publishers too Mike 03 Nov 22 #1
Time for those in the know to list all the books we need to read. Dem2theMax Nov 22 #2
Do you have a bookstore in your area? vapor2 Nov 23 #8
I honestly don't know, but I can certainly search for one. Dem2theMax Nov 23 #10
It will be challenged...states rights vs Ntl. Not sure they will get very far with this one. PortTack Nov 22 #3
The internet makes book-banning nearly impossible FakeNoose Nov 22 #4
On the contrary Nasruddin Nov 22 #5
Who controls the internet? intheflow Nov 23 #6
Most contemporary book bans aren't bans at all Prairie Gates Nov 23 #7
Red China says hi... Blue_Tires Nov 23 #9

Mike 03

(17,381 posts)
1. Concerned about self-censorship by publishers too
Fri Nov 22, 2024, 05:46 PM
Nov 22

There were probably more than one hundred books about Trump and/or the danger he poses to democracy published over the last 8 years. Many DUers have read one or more of these books. I can't provide a link, but I recall hearing that there is an effort by GOP politicians to resurrect defamation laws that are far more expansive in their definition of what constitutes defamation, allowing far more people to sue. Even in the case of frivolous lawsuits, such lawsuits can cost millions to defend.

For that reason I fear that publishers may be more reluctant to publish books critical of Trump and his administration, or even books of the type Ruth Ben-Ghiat, Timothy Snyder and Anne Applebaum write: cautionary histories and reflections about how democracies are weakened and destroyed.

(EDIT: The United Kingdom is an example of a place where authors can be sued and legally harassed for writing truthful but critical works. See the nightmare Catherine Belton went through after publishing "Putin's People: How the KGB Took Back Russia and then Took on the West," a book highly critical of several Russian oligarchs.)

We'll see though. Perhaps these worries are unjustified.

Dem2theMax

(10,406 posts)
2. Time for those in the know to list all the books we need to read.
Fri Nov 22, 2024, 08:27 PM
Nov 22

Can't afford it, but I'll buy them anyway.

vapor2

(1,633 posts)
8. Do you have a bookstore in your area?
Sat Nov 23, 2024, 11:16 AM
Nov 23

I can buy books for $1 which are donated and some are or will be banned. Found Adam Schiff's book and Jaime Raskin's , both for $1

Dem2theMax

(10,406 posts)
10. I honestly don't know, but I can certainly search for one.
Sat Nov 23, 2024, 03:09 PM
Nov 23

I'm in a smaller city, but there's a really large one nearby and there has to be multiple bookstores where I could find used books. Thanks for the suggestion!

Nasruddin

(869 posts)
5. On the contrary
Fri Nov 22, 2024, 11:31 PM
Nov 22

The lesson has been that it makes censorship and compliance extremely effective and at a favorable cost.
It's like you have control over the paper AND the pens. And the fingerprint of every hand.

intheflow

(29,056 posts)
6. Who controls the internet?
Sat Nov 23, 2024, 10:55 AM
Nov 23

Trump’s FCC could throttle it. Ban the internet entirely, akin to tik tok bans.

Prairie Gates

(3,574 posts)
7. Most contemporary book bans aren't bans at all
Sat Nov 23, 2024, 11:11 AM
Nov 23

They restrict access to books through particular institutions (schools, libraries), while maintaining availability through the market. That's why some bookstores will have a "Banned Books" table near the front of their stores, seemingly without irony. Actual book bans criminalize the availability of a book through any means whatsoever. One of the primary enforcers of books bans prior to US v. One Book Called Ulysses were custom officials, who would seize books coming from Europe and through Canada (Britain and Canada had similar obscenity laws to the US). Genuine book bans criminalized publication and distribution.

Now, to be sure, banning access through institutions is an effective ban in many ways. Many people can only afford access to books through schools and libraries. It also shapes curriculum and deprofessionalized teaching when legislatures decide which books should be taught in classes. And that's all bad and should be resisted. But one of the reasons conservatives are successful with these is because we've misnamed them. DeSantis laughed about the "book bans" and said you can get any of these books in Florida bookstores or through Amazon. And he was right. And that weakens our argument. We need to be more precise about what we're talking about.

Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Advocates fear national b...