General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsTrump plans to attend Wednesday's Supreme Court hearing on his bid to limit birthright citizenship
WASHINGTON (AP) President Donald Trump plans to sit in on Wednesdays Supreme Court hearing on birthright citizenship, making him the first sitting president to attend oral arguments at the nations highest court.
The Republican presidents official schedule, sent out by the White House, included a stop at the Supreme Court, where justices will hear Trumps appeal of a lower court ruling that struck down his executive order limiting birthright citizenship.
The order, which Trump signed on the first day of his second term, declared that children born to parents who are in the United States illegally or temporarily are not American citizens. Its an about-face from the long-standing view that the Constitutions 14th Amendment and federal law since 1940 confer citizenship to everyone born on American soil, with narrow exceptions.
Its not the first time Trump has considered showing up for a high court hearing. Last year, Trump said that he badly wanted to attend a hearing on whether he overstepped federal law with his sweeping tariffs, but he decided against it, saying it would have been a distraction.
https://apnews.com/article/trump-supreme-court-hearing-birthright-citizenship-e069e683149d23fe59e4679732c084f5
PATRICK
(12,401 posts)isn't too distracting now. No snoring please.
spanone
(141,695 posts)leftstreet
(40,855 posts)sinkingfeeling
(57,843 posts)Orrex
(67,153 posts)dweller
(28,461 posts)tanyev
(49,328 posts)newdeal2
(5,460 posts)Maybe Alito or Clarence will let him sit in their chairs. Or he can give them redecorating tips.
spanone
(141,695 posts)WheelWalker
(9,402 posts)And he desperately needs more.
Tree Lady
(13,303 posts)That actually will be better than other meetings where he falls asleep.
LetMyPeopleVote
(180,171 posts)If his radical gambit is likely to lose, why bother with an unprecedented presidential appearance at the high court? There are two prevailing explanations.
Link to tweet
https://www.ms.now/rachel-maddow-show/maddowblog/why-trump-attending-supreme-court-birthright-citizenship-arguments
President Donald Trump will be watching oral arguments today as the Supreme Court weighs whether the president holds the power to end birthright citizenship. [ ]
Trumps presence at the court is significant. He will be the first known sitting U.S. president to attend oral arguments before the high court, according to the Supreme Court Historical Society.
By way of explanation, the president told reporters on Tuesday that he intended to sit in on oral arguments because I have listened to this argument for so long. (A day later, Im not entirely sure what that was supposed to mean.)....
So why bother with an unprecedented presidential appearance at the high court? There are two prevailing explanations though theyre not mutually exclusive, and both could be true.
The first is that this is part of a ham-fisted intimidation campaign: By literally showing up in person, its possible that Trump, who appointed a third of the courts justices, thinks he can apply extra pressure to those who will decide the cases fate.
If this is the goal, the president is likely to be disappointed. Unlike congressional Republicans, justices dont want to be seen as obedient White House loyalists, and its easy to imagine Trumps stunt backfiring.
The other theory is that Trump recognizes the fact that the Supreme Court wont let him rewrite constitutional law through an executive order, so he went to oral arguments as a political tactic intended to deliver an anti-immigrant message which the White House sees as more politically salient than other issues that are dominating the public conversation, such as the war with Iran and high gas prices.
The big thing for Trump is to be seen putting up a fight, Politico noted. This policy always a Hail Mary from a legal perspective is as much about signaling to the presidents base as it is a serious attempt to change the law.
Whatever the explanation, if the president expects his order to be upheld, he probably ought to start lowering his expectations. Watch this space.