General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsIndictments Aren't Victory Laps - Trump celebrates Maduro's capture, but federal court reality looms
https://www.meidasplus.com/p/indictments-arent-victory-lapsTrump celebrates Maduros capture, but federal court reality looms, constitutional guardrails tighten, and Judge Hellerstein reminds presidents that indictments begin cases, not victories.
Michael Cohen and MeidasTouch Network
Jan 04, 2026
On Monday, when Nicolás Maduro and his wife, Cilia Flores, are wheeled into a federal courtroom in the Southern District of New York, they will do the least cinematic thing imaginable: they will plead not guilty to every single count. No confession. No dramatic collapse. No instant justice montage for Fox News. Just the beginning of a very long, very complicated federal case; one that Trump and his chest-thumping administration appear to fundamentally misunderstand.
I know something about that courtroom. I know something about that judge. And I know something about what happens when prosecutors overestimate theatrics and underestimate the Constitution.
Maduro, improbably, could not have landed in a better courtroom if he spun the wheel himself.
The case is assigned to Judge Alvin K. Hellerstein, a senior U.S. District Judge appointed by President Bill Clinton in 1998. A serious jurist. A constitutional hawk. A man with zero patience for executive-branch arrogance masquerading as law enforcement. Hes also the same judge who, in July 2020, looked at what the Trump administration and Bill Barr did to meremanding me to prison because I planned to publish Disloyaland called it exactly what it was: retaliation.
Judge Hellerstein ruled that the government violated my First Amendment rights, imposed an unprecedented and unconstitutional gag order, and attempted to silence speech as a condition of release. He said, flatly, that in over two decades on the bench he had never seen conditions like that. Then he ordered my immediate release.
More at link
Bettie
(19,299 posts)how any US court has jurisdiction over anything that happens in another country, but the rule of law is more of a fuzzy "What does the orange monster want" than actual law these days.
Amaryllis
(10,988 posts)And that's the problem that Trump faces. The US does not have the authority to do what it just did. It does not have the authority to try a foreign national, especially the leader (elected or not), and the judge clearly knows that. Maduro and his wife will almost certainly be freed, at which point Trump has egg on his face.
Bettie
(19,299 posts)than I do, Laws mean nothing to the Republican party....and even less to the orange monster.
snot
(11,528 posts)the claimed deleterious effects within the US of drug trafficking supposedly facilitated by Maduro.
(I note, for comparison, that the same problem affected proceedings against Julian Assange: he wasn't a citizen, neither he not Wikileaks had any office or other continuing presence in the US, there was no allegation that he'd done anything arguably illegal while travelling the US, he hadn't even actually hacked any info from the US or US-based entities; he simply published info leaked by others evidencing US crimes. We nonetheless indicted him for a death penalty-type offense.)
I think Maduro's claimed drug trafficking is the legal thread this hangs from, while the argument that we're merely reclaiming oil stolen from our oligarchs is meant to reassure MAGAts that our action really is in the interests of Amuhrica after all.
Blue Full Moon
(3,181 posts)RockRaven
(18,741 posts)Just sayin'
Bettie
(19,299 posts)while also recognizing that what his happening is incredibly dangerous.
This sets a precedent that allows him to literally use our military to kidnap any world leader and take over governance of any country in the world.
SARose
(1,831 posts)Why?
Maduro is sitting on a butt load of petro dollars stashed in some vault somewhere.
Actually, Maduro is probably much, much wealthier than Trump.
Putting on my magical thinking cap I think Maduro will get a Trump pardon. Do you?
Quid pro quo, baby!
snot
(11,528 posts)But is it certain that the case will stay in that court?