Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

AverageOldGuy

(3,362 posts)
Wed Dec 31, 2025, 07:59 PM Dec 31

"They joined what they joined."

One day Trump’s attempt to establish a dictatorship in the US — supported by about 40 percent of the population – will be over and the rest of us will have to restore our democratic republic.

The question then will be how to deal with Trump’s followers. The example of Nazi Germany after WW II may be instructive.

“Historians have a word for Germans who joined the Nazi party, not because they hated Jews, but out of a hope for restored patriotism, or a sense of economic anxiety, or a hope to preserve their religious values, or dislike of their opponents, or raw political opportunism, or convenience, or ignorance, or greed.

That word is “Nazi.” Nobody cares about their motives anymore.

They joined what they joined. They lent their support and their moral approval. And, in so doing, they bound themselves to everything that came after. Who cares any more what particular knot they used in the binding?”

― A.R. Moxon


When Trump and his dictatorship are gone, and we are faced with dealing with his supporters, remember this:

“They joined what they joined.”

Then, treat them accordingly.
28 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
"They joined what they joined." (Original Post) AverageOldGuy Dec 31 OP
I don't have any confidence we'll be tough enough. -nt CrispyQ Dec 31 #1
That's because we're not coming off ten years of killing each other by the millions. Iggo Dec 31 #4
they have each earned a lamp post of their own rampartd Jan 1 #16
Ah yes, HW and his lamposts. He was speaking prophecy about his own. Clouds Passing Jan 1 #23
Well stated. ShazzieB Jan 1 #24
You are correct. But the stench of "Nazi" has long endured, as will the stench of "Trumpism", horrific in it's own way. Joinfortmill Jan 1 #27
Am reluctant to break friendships with this sentiment. cachukis Dec 31 #2
Unless they can publicly admit they were wrong, FoxNewsSucks Dec 31 #3
I'd have a really hard time accepting even that. They've gone too far. paleotn Dec 31 #7
THAT is the one redeeming quality. calimary Dec 31 #9
If what happened to the to the surviving Confederates after Civil War is anything to go by, the nelm Dec 31 #5
Some things are unforgivable. paleotn Dec 31 #6
Told a Gropenfuhrer MAGAt a couple weeks ago...... KS Toronado Dec 31 #8
Exactly. they are just Nazis. Martin68 Dec 31 #10
Excellent points and moniss Dec 31 #11
Thank you for the links Wild blueberry Jan 1 #19
With trump starting to screw them popsdenver Dec 31 #12
Hahaha Joinfortmill Jan 1 #28
Or, czarjak Dec 31 #13
I believe England once sent their "problems" to Australia 3825-87867 Dec 31 #14
"Shame there are no empty continents..." Iggo Jan 1 #17
Treat them like adults who are responsible for their actions. hay rick Jan 1 #15
No references, memorials, naming, plaques statues, etc AllyCat Jan 1 #18
I think that a good open trial of the leaders 1WorldHope Jan 1 #20
That's one of my favorite quotes TxGuitar Jan 1 #21
Absolutely! BurnDoubt Jan 1 #22
A handful of them might care or see the light, but I suspect we're the country of: meadowlander Jan 1 #25
Thank You. The End. Amen. Done. Joinfortmill Jan 1 #26

Iggo

(49,662 posts)
4. That's because we're not coming off ten years of killing each other by the millions.
Wed Dec 31, 2025, 08:55 PM
Dec 31

And I think I’m okay with that. (And by “that” I mean not hanging them from lamp posts.)

ShazzieB

(22,220 posts)
24. Well stated.
Thu Jan 1, 2026, 03:52 PM
Jan 1

As horrible as MAGA support of Trump’s evils has been, it doesn't touch what the Nazis did. Would he be willing to do everything Hitler did, given the chance? Sure. But he hasn't had the chance yet, and his time is rapidly running out as his health deteriorates.

Also, there is no MAGA party that people can join, and no one is required to tell anyone else who they voted for in this country, because our elections operate by secret ballot. Not all of his supporters are Republicans, and not all Republicans are Trump fans. And even if one equalled the other, identifying all the Republicans would not be easy.

Voter registration would supply party affiliation information in some states, but not all states ask voters to indicate their partisan affiliations on voter registration forms. My state, Illinois, is one of those. (More info on this topic can be found here: https://ballotpedia.org/Partisan_affiliations_of_registered_voters)

Granted, a lot of Trump voters are easy to recognize, but without a reliable way to verify not only party affiliation but who actually voted for the Orange Hellbeast, there is no way to accurately identify all of his supporters or their level of loyalty. And besides, ain't nobody got time for that! We'll be too busy putting this country back together to spend time and money trying to figure out who all the Trump voters are so they can be punished accordingly.

Even in Germany, all the registered members of the Nazi party weren't punished for being Nazis, and not all card carrying party members were complete monsters (for one example, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oskar_Schindler).

Some leaders were tried for their crimes and sentenced accordingly, but many of the rank and file members were not. More info: https://www.theholocaustexplained.org/survival-and-legacy/postwar-trials-and-denazification/

In short, there is no reliable or just way to identify and punish every Trump voter even if we wanted to (and I for one question the advisability of that). I'm all for punishing those who did illegal things (like the ICE thugs and thise who gave them their orders, for examples), but it is not a crime to vote for a horrible candidate or support a horrible president in this country, and God help us all if either of those things ever becomes a crime.

Joinfortmill

(20,097 posts)
27. You are correct. But the stench of "Nazi" has long endured, as will the stench of "Trumpism", horrific in it's own way.
Thu Jan 1, 2026, 07:17 PM
Jan 1

Many, if not most, of these people did not hide who they voted for, they bragged about it. We know who these people are in our lives, and we will always know that they possess what I think of as the 'Mean Gene". Also, they are dumber than rocks.

calimary

(89,047 posts)
9. THAT is the one redeeming quality.
Wed Dec 31, 2025, 09:23 PM
Dec 31

They need to admit, publicly, that they were WRONG. And that they made a huge mistake based on what was pretty clearly the preferences of a segment of the public, NOT all the public. Not a large segment of the population. It’s a smaller group. And I suspect it’s already shrinking. Maybe not enough to be noticeable, but I bet it’s getting there. And I think it’ll be gathering momentum as the weeks pass.

the nelm

(244 posts)
5. If what happened to the to the surviving Confederates after Civil War is anything to go by,
Wed Dec 31, 2025, 09:08 PM
Dec 31

we're likely doomed to repeat the same mistakes once again. Bad as that may sound. Thing is we are still in some ways, a 150 years later, dealing with that same mindset.

paleotn

(21,576 posts)
6. Some things are unforgivable.
Wed Dec 31, 2025, 09:10 PM
Dec 31

Harsh, yes, but there are some things that are so far beyond the pale that forgiveness is impossible. Consciously shitting on our democracy, and the countless Americans who died to preserve liberty, in order to setup some half ass autocracy is one of them. And it's not even a remotely competent autocracy. It's led by one of the dumbest, most vile excuses for a human ever to live. The unpardonable sin. His followers, no matter how rank or file, should never be allowed to escape it.

KS Toronado

(23,060 posts)
8. Told a Gropenfuhrer MAGAt a couple weeks ago......
Wed Dec 31, 2025, 09:14 PM
Dec 31

" 10 years from now you'll be telling everybody you was smart enough not to vote for him "

moniss

(8,731 posts)
11. Excellent points and
Wed Dec 31, 2025, 09:43 PM
Dec 31

"de-Nazification" was a hard lesson for many Germans and it lives on even today in the descendants in Germany. Although some are trying to bring back an influence of the hard right fascism the aftermath of it is so deep in the memory of older Germans that they have come out in demonstrations against the AfD where they had not been demonstrators about much before. Here is a link to some letters to The Guardian about the rise of fascism among some in Germany and excellent points about some of the factors used to "sway' people and some factors that seduce people. Also a link to an excellent article written by young journalists about this rise in Germany.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2025/dec/29/key-factors-in-the-unstoppable-rise-of-fascists-in-germany

https://youth.europa.eu/news/fascism-rise-germany-whats-driving-young-and-old-streets-today_en

popsdenver

(1,566 posts)
12. With trump starting to screw them
Wed Dec 31, 2025, 10:04 PM
Dec 31

my feelings towards all the MAGAot Voters is:

You grew it, you chew it, MUNCH MUNCH MUNCH........

3825-87867

(1,806 posts)
14. I believe England once sent their "problems" to Australia
Wed Dec 31, 2025, 11:08 PM
Dec 31

Shame there are no empty continents to "deport" the American Nazis to. Of course, there's always the moon or...Musk's Mars!
Deportation of American Nazi Sympathizers and trumpers...has an "even up" ring to it.

Greenland? Maybe a deal with Russia to deport them to a couple of those rather frigid islands above the Arctic Circle?
Deport American Nazis and trump sympathizers...2029 ICE? Turn-about is fair play.
They can become "rational anarchists" ala 'The Moon is a Harsh Mistress" in the cold.

Just letting them know might be enough for some. However, there are others who will never capitulate. Miller, Vought et al. They can learn about cold weather survival. More humane than El Salvador.

Iggo

(49,662 posts)
17. "Shame there are no empty continents..."
Thu Jan 1, 2026, 03:40 AM
Jan 1

There’s one. Pretty cold down there, though.

I do like your Mars idea.

hay rick

(9,362 posts)
15. Treat them like adults who are responsible for their actions.
Thu Jan 1, 2026, 01:07 AM
Jan 1

They betrayed their country. They betrayed you and me.

AllyCat

(18,530 posts)
18. No references, memorials, naming, plaques statues, etc
Thu Jan 1, 2026, 11:16 AM
Jan 1

OF ANY KIND to the members of this administration or its supporters. None. History only of the horrors of this regime.

No coddling of “all Americans regardless of their past” and tolerance of their views ANYWHERE. Unless that person admits wrongdoing and actively works to repair some of the damage they have done…no awards, no elected positions, no MAGA gear, reduced job opportunities, and in many cases, TRIALS and PUNISHMENT.

Everything related to this regime squashed.

Rebuild the WH. Reparations to the people wrongly incarcerated, the families of those killed.

1WorldHope

(1,862 posts)
20. I think that a good open trial of the leaders
Thu Jan 1, 2026, 01:13 PM
Jan 1

with all of their sins revealed and a just punishment, should be the direction we go. We can't control people's thoughts or punish them for those thoughts. But if those thoughts lead to punishable actions, then they should be held accountable. We will have so many trials after this, and there are so many who have broken the law that need to be dealt with that our hands will be full for a while. Purging those we disagree with is what they have been doing.

BurnDoubt

(1,477 posts)
22. Absolutely!
Thu Jan 1, 2026, 03:00 PM
Jan 1

When AI makes them obsolete will they still hate their Brothers for "The Great Replacement"?
They've already failed their Competency test.
Will they like what comes next?
Sadly, they didn't just fuck themselves.
We're ruled by Sociopathic Deplorables.
Hillary was right about almost everything.
And it cost us the Election. Along with Scullduggery.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»"They joined what they jo...