General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsAI promises to free up time. But what if it spares us from learning, writing, painting and exploring the world?
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2025/mar/30/ai-promises-to-free-up-time-but-what-if-it-spares-us-from-learning-writing-painting-and-exploring-the-worldIf I reduced my existence to a series of ChatGPT prompts, the act of my living is only shorter – not better
I side with the writer and philosopher John Gray, who in his terrifying work of eco-nihilism Straw Dogs balances the fact that human beings are a plague animal who are wrecking the biosphere that supports them with the idea that we have made our lives easier through technology. Gray, in particular, calls anesthetised dentistry an “unmixed blessing”.
. . .
In matters of technology, I operate on one guiding principle: I give my computer the work that I do not want to do, and that I gain little by doing myself. The ideal model of the computer, I think, is the calculator: if I sat there with a piece of paper and a pen, I could probably do most of the sums myself that I ask my calculator to do. But that would take time, and I’m a busy man (lots of cool bird videos to watch), and so I give it to a computer to work out.
. . .
It’s increasingly clear that a computer could live my life for me, all while I atrophy, never going outside. But if I reduced my existence to a series of ChatGPT prompts, the act of my living is only shorter, not better. And despite what tech bros tell me, those are not the same thing.

bamagal62
(3,853 posts)Quite disturbing.
Nigrum Cattus
(450 posts)ALL A.I. is designed to replace humans -
Only humans should replace humans -
A.I. is a corporate wet dream -
https://www.freepik.com/premium-photo/ukraine-khmelnitsky-august-2019-metal-robot-form-skeleton-dark-background_16987294.htm#fromView=keyword&page=1&position=5&uuid=fa520b6f-c6b8-46d2-968b-f5ec541bf3a6&query=Terminator+Robot
anciano
(1,739 posts)I occasionally use it to help clarify my thinking for an important text or email, and also to save time doing research when trying to better understand a situation that is unfamiliar to me.
But it is only a tool to use when needed, it doesn't impair my enjoyment of daily life at all.
alarimer
(17,071 posts)And AI can be very inaccurate.
erronis
(18,659 posts)It is all in the hands of the black-box purveyor.
Trust Us. We Know All.
(Sounds like religion to me.)
usonian
(16,850 posts)but will need smart human intervention.
In short, only complete crap can be completely automated. And ask Apple, AI f$cks up even at simple things. Meaningless stuff like catching a plane departure.
erronis
(18,659 posts)But they really need a specialist to make sure they aren't "hallucinating".